‘First Shift’: Why Worst Cop Movie Is Curiously Watchable

German director Uwe Boll has the distinction of being one of the world’s worst filmmakers yet nevertheless manages to make movies that are oddly watchable.
‘First Shift’: Why Worst Cop Movie Is Curiously Watchable
NYPD homicide detective Deo Russo (Gino Anthony Pesi, L) apprehending a suspect in "First Shift." Hit and Run Productions/Quiver Distribution
Mark Jackson
Updated:
0:00

NR | 1h 29m | Cop Drama | Aug. 30, 2024

German director Uwe Boll is considered by many in the film industry to be one of the worst movie directors of all time. But after seeing “The Insufferable Groo” (2018), I would have to say that particular description and top billing goes to the subject of that movie, director Stephen Groo, who is in an incredibly bizarre class all his own.

But Boll is notable as a bad director. He has a curious knack for creating abominable movies that will, nevertheless, somehow manage to hold your attention. Part of the problem is that he’s got European cinematic style tastes. Meaning extreme slowness; realism and naturalism to the point of cross-eyed boredom for Americans.

Boll announced his retirement from filmmaking in 2016, then made a comeback with a German movie in 2022. Now he’s back with his first English-language movie in eight years.

Mismatched Partners

The movie opens with an over-prolonged documentation of world-weary NYPD homicide detective veteran Deo Russo’s (Gino Anthony Pesi) morning routine. Alarm clock, blending himself some kind of powdered breakfast smoothie, washing the glass, teeth-brushing, wardrobe consideration, dressing, apartment-leaving, walking, walking, walking, walking, subway-taking, subway-taking, subway-taking, and so on and so forth.
NYPD homicide detective Deo Russo (Gino Anthony Pesi) contemplates the world from his roof, in "First Shift." (Hit and Run Productions/Quiver Distribution)
NYPD homicide detective Deo Russo (Gino Anthony Pesi) contemplates the world from his roof, in "First Shift." Hit and Run Productions/Quiver Distribution

And yet here’s the thing: even though I was bored out of my mind, I found I was still watching. I asked myself, “Why are you still watching? Oh yeah, I’m on the job.” But I might have still been watching regardless. It’s interesting that Boll somehow manages to accomplish this. More on this later.

When Russo arrives at the precinct, his commanding officer (Tia Dionne Hodge) informs the antisocial detective that he has a new partner, and that she might be a breath of fresh air for him. She also hints that a romance might bloom between them, which seems like quite an odd and rabidly unprofessional thing for a law enforcement officer to tell her underling.

And so the single, introverted detective meets his extroverted, perky new motor-mouthed partner named Angela Dutton (Kristen Renton) who has transferred from Atlanta.

NYPD homicide detective Angela (Kristen Renton), in "First Shift." (Hit and Run Productions/Quiver Distribution)
NYPD homicide detective Angela (Kristen Renton), in "First Shift." Hit and Run Productions/Quiver Distribution

Most of the movie involves these two engaging in stereotypical odd couple banter and arguments, interspersed with two other crime scenes happening simultaneously, elsewhere, that they’re unaware of.

One involves a double homicide, perpetrated by two goons of a larger-fish gangster, and the other involves a man (James McMenamin) who’s locked himself in a bathroom with a bottle of suspicious-looking pills, while his significant other (Brandi Bravo) bangs on the door telling him she knows what he’s up to in there.

Detective Angela (Kristen Renton) contemplates her partner Deo Russo (Gino Anthony Pesi) on his apartment building roof, in "First Shift." (Hit and Run Productions/Quiver Distribution)
Detective Angela (Kristen Renton) contemplates her partner Deo Russo (Gino Anthony Pesi) on his apartment building roof, in "First Shift." Hit and Run Productions/Quiver Distribution

Deo and Angela (which mean, uh, “God,” and “Angel”) are of course both connected to these scenes, and we find out how, later.

The movie ends with actual coming attraction signage for a sequel, which had me thinking I’d watched the first episode of a TV series by mistake. But no. It’s just an Uwe Boll movie.

Find something positive to say? Anyone bemused by Boll’s bizarre ability to bungle the basics of storytelling will find lots of entertaining examples in “First Shift.” It plays like it was made by little green Martians in alien film school who made a movie to show what they’ve learned after studying the buddy-cop genre.

Detective Angela (Kristen Renton) shares a drink with her partner, Deo Russo (Gino Anthony Pesi), after a rough day, in "First Shift." (Hit and Run Productions/Quiver Distribution)
Detective Angela (Kristen Renton) shares a drink with her partner, Deo Russo (Gino Anthony Pesi), after a rough day, in "First Shift." Hit and Run Productions/Quiver Distribution

Why We Watch Boll Nevertheless

Many of Boll’s movies have seen international theatrical releases. Many bad directors keep low profiles due to direct-to-video releases and one-off theater rentals, but Boll’s work receives huge exposure.
Why? He gets some big names, sometimes. His casting choices would seem to be primarily motivated by finding big name actors who will work with him. Similar to Stephen Groo landing Jack Black in one of his films, without being aware of the fact that it’s because Groo’s films are so mind-bogglingly egregious, that of course Jack Black would love to be in one, because that’s absolutely something Jack Black would do. A good example of Boll casting is Tara Reid playing an archaeologist. Think about that for a minute. Also Ray Liotta as an evil sorcerer.

Boll’s work typically has high production value. If Boll’s movies looked like they were shot in somebody’s back yard (the way the insufferable Groo’s movies actually are) he would have been railroaded out of Hollywood long ago. But because they look like they have serious money backing them, they give off a whiff of possibly being a mere misfire by an actually decent director. His movies remain watchable because his choices are so out of left field that they leave you looking at the screen like a German Shepherd tilting it’s head to one side, and then the other, trying to figure out what you just saw, and why.

“First Shift” was released on VOD and in select theaters August 30.
Promotional poster for "First Shift." (Hit and Run Productions/Quiver Distribution)
Promotional poster for "First Shift." Hit and Run Productions/Quiver Distribution
‘First Shift’ Director: Uwe Boll Starring: Gino Anthony Pesi, Kristen Renton, Tia Dionne Hodge, James McMenamin, Brandi Bravo, Willie C. Carpenter Not Rated Running Time: 1 hour, 20 minutes Release Date: Aug. 30, 2024 Rating: 1 and 1/2 stars out of 5
Would you like to see other kinds of arts and culture articles? Please email us your story ideas or feedback at [email protected]
Mark Jackson
Mark Jackson
Film Critic
Mark Jackson is the chief film critic for The Epoch Times. In addition to the world’s number-one storytelling vehicle—film, he enjoys martial arts, weightlifting, motorcycles, vision questing, rock-climbing, qigong, oil painting, and human rights activism. Mark earned a bachelor's degree in philosophy from Williams College, followed by a classical theater training, and has 20 years’ experience as a New York professional actor, working in theater, commercials, and television daytime dramas. He recently narrated the Epoch Times audiobook “How the Specter of Communism is Ruling Our World,” which is available on iTunes and Audible. Mr. Jackson is a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic.