US Cities Where You'll Pay More or Less for Hotels Versus Airbnbs

Hotels are more costly compared to Airbnb in the majority of American cities.
US Cities Where You'll Pay More or Less for Hotels Versus Airbnbs
The entrance to the Pfister Hotel on North Jefferson Street in downtown Milwaukee, on July 11, 2019. According to Upgraded Points, the average nightly cost of a hotel in Milwaukee is $350.50, as opposed to $138.31 for an Airbnb. Tony Savino/Dreamstime/TNS
Tribune News Service
Updated:
0:00
By Patrick Clarke From TravelPulse

Travelers have plenty of accommodation choices when they travel this summer because of the emergence of home-sharing platforms such as Airbnb, making it easier to save on their stay.

Upgraded Points recently analyzed average nightly rates for hotels and Airbnbs in 100 of the largest cities across the United States to reveal which places it pays to book a hotel stay over an Airbnb (entire home) or vice versa.

“Hotels have long been the go-to choice for travelers seeking comfort and convenience, but Airbnb has grown in popularity as an alternative, offering unique stays and a taste of local life,” Keri Stooksbury, editor-in-chief at Upgraded Points, said in a statement. “When choosing between comfort and uniqueness, cost plays a huge role, and we wanted to find just where you could find the best accommodation deals.”

Airbnb was determined to be the most cost-effective accommodation option in 71 of 100 cities examined, with an average nightly rate of $156 compared to $208 for hotels. In some cities in the Midwest, the difference was roughly $200 per night.

However, the difference was minimal in other cities such as San Jose, California, and McAllen, Texas, where nightly rates were separated by just $1.50.

Top U.S. Cities Where Hotels Cost More Than Airbnbs

Milwaukee—Hotel average: $350.50 vs Airbnb average: $138.31

Chicago—Hotel average: $363.95 vs Airbnb average: $165.56

Omaha, Nebraska—Hotel average: $343.30 vs Airbnb average: $145.06

Cleveland—Hotel average: $322.29 vs Airbnb average: $125.09

Charleston, South Carolina—Hotel average: $395.38 vs Airbnb average: $209.72

Boston; New Haven, Connecticut; Detroit; Providence, Rhode Island; and Seattle also made the top 10 cities where hotels are more expensive than Airbnbs.

Top U.S. Cities Where Airbnbs Cost More Than Hotels

Madison, Wisconsin—Airbnb average: $223.49 vs hotel average: $167.18

Tucson, Arizona—Airbnb average: $142.07 vs hotel average: $99.40

Bakersfield, California—Airbnb average: $163.89 vs hotel average: $123.48

Jackson, Mississippi—Airbnb average: $150.68 vs hotel average: $113.20

Scranton, Pennsylvania—Airbnb average: $185 vs hotel average: $150

Other top cities where hotels are cheaper than Airbnbs on average include Fort Myers, Florida; Baton Rouge, Louisiana; Colorado Springs, Colorado; Grand Rapids, Michigan; and Stockton, California.

Copyright 2024 Northstar Travel Media, LLC. Visit at travelpulse.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
Dear Readers: We would love to hear from you. What topics would you like to read about? Please send your feedback and tips to [email protected].