‘Love at First Sight’: Is It Fate or Just a Numbers Game?

The premise of love at first sight isn’t new. This film’s innovation is the running commentary of statistics and probability of love happening.
‘Love at First Sight’: Is It Fate or Just a Numbers Game?
Hadley Sullivan (Haley Lu Richardson) and Oliver Jones (Ben Hardy) in "Love at First Sight." Rob Baker Ashton/Netflix
Mark Jackson
Updated:
0:00

How does love happen? How do, say, two bookstore owners who hate each other (“You’ve Got Mail”) fall in love? How does a famous American actress fall for a non-famous British bookstore owner (“Notting Hill”) after a chance encounter?

In “Love at First Sight,” Cupid shoots two of his arrows in the middle of an airport. The love-struck man and woman start detecting that sweet pain immediately, and then realize that they’re beyond rescue later, at 1) the preemptive memorial of the man’s mom (who’s not dead yet), and 2) the woman’s dad’s second wedding. Got that?

“Love at First Sight” is a reminder that falling in love isn’t always supposed to make sense, can happen when you least expect it, in the midst of drama and sadness and in the craziest places. It explores the roles that fate and choice play in our lives, and how, to use the hoary cliché, whenever God closes a door, he opens a window.

Oliver Jones (Ben Hardy) and Hadley Sullivan (Haley Lu Richardson) fall in love quickly, in "Love at First Sight." (Rob Baker Ashton/Netflix)
Oliver Jones (Ben Hardy) and Hadley Sullivan (Haley Lu Richardson) fall in love quickly, in "Love at First Sight." Rob Baker Ashton/Netflix
The premise of love at first sight is obviously not new. What’s innovative here are the statistics and probability of it happening, continually being explained to the audience in an ongoing sidebar commentary.

Story

Hadley (Haley Lu Richardson) flies to London to attend her dad’s (Rob Delaney) wedding. She’s still not over her parents’ divorce and resents him for bailing on her and her mom and starting a brand new life in another country.

Hadley has issues with being on time, and also flying in airplanes, and being therefore four minutes late for her flight—misses it. She manages to get a seat on the next one and, during the wait, meets a blond Brit named Oliver Jones (Ben Hardy).

He’s a good-looking math nerd (hence the running commentary about percentages and statistics from the narrator/fate/Greek chorus (Jameela Jamil), who pops up as different characters: a flight attendant, an immigration officer, a wedding guest, and so on. She makes it clear that love is just as much about choice as it is about fate.

Oliver Jones (Ben Hardy) and Hadley Sullivan (Haley Lu Richardson), in "Love at First Sight." (Rob Baker Ashton/Netflix)
Oliver Jones (Ben Hardy) and Hadley Sullivan (Haley Lu Richardson), in "Love at First Sight." Rob Baker Ashton/Netflix

Anyway, enter Cupid. Twang! Twang! The imminent lovebirds grab some food at the airport, and then, wouldn’t ya know—wind up seated next to each other on the flight.

Hadley Sullivan (Haley Lu Richardson) and Oliver Jones (Ben Hardy), in "Love at First Sight." (Rob Baker Ashton/Netflix)
Hadley Sullivan (Haley Lu Richardson) and Oliver Jones (Ben Hardy), in "Love at First Sight." Rob Baker Ashton/Netflix

Then, arriving in London, they promptly encounter a dead phone-battery situation wherein their exchanged info gets irrevocably lost. And so while Hadley’s at dad’s wedding, Oliver attends mom’s (Sally Phillips) living memorial.

Hadley Sullivan (Haley Lu Richardson) loses Oliver Jones's phone number and rushes out of the airport to find him, in "Love at First Sight." (Rob Baker Ashton/Netflix)
Hadley Sullivan (Haley Lu Richardson) loses Oliver Jones's phone number and rushes out of the airport to find him, in "Love at First Sight." Rob Baker Ashton/Netflix
Oliver’s mum wanted to be present at that inevitable gathering now, and actually hear the nice things everyone will eventually say about her, instead of missing the party. It’s a nice idea, except that eldest son Oliver, seeing the world mathematically, as he does, can’t understand why mom won’t do chemo, and is understandably distraught, albeit in a British, stiff upper lip kind of way.

Meanwhile, in the last book Hadley was gifted before her dad left—Charles Dickens’s “Our Mutual Friend”—she reads that well-known quote: “Is it better to have had a good thing and lost it, or never to have had it?” She overhears a wedding guest mention a memorial happening somewhere across town and impetuously bolts from the wedding.

Oliver Jones (Ben Hardy, C) and his brother Luther (Tom Taylor, R) attend their mother's living memorial costume party, in "Love at First Sight." (Rob Baker Ashton/Netflix)
Oliver Jones (Ben Hardy, C) and his brother Luther (Tom Taylor, R) attend their mother's living memorial costume party, in "Love at First Sight." Rob Baker Ashton/Netflix

Overall

The main problem with a film with this particular title is that the lovebirds must be twitterpated from the get-go, which can easily result in the whole thing hitting a ceiling early and having no place else to go. This story builds well.

We get a glimpse into their characters, and why they grew up with three specific fears. These fears (which include a shared loathing of mayonnaise) end up pushing them away from each other. What are the chances they will end up back together again?

Narrator/Fate (Jameela Jamil), in "Love at First Sight." (Rob Baker Ashton/Netflix)
Narrator/Fate (Jameela Jamil), in "Love at First Sight." Rob Baker Ashton/Netflix

Fate brought Hadley and Oliver together, but decisions count too, as does courage. When Hadley tells her dad, “It sounds insane, and it makes no sense,” his answer is, “It’s not supposed to.”

Particularly baffling to the logical Oliver is the fact that love isn’t logical. His mother’s memorial makes him realize that he has spent his entire life hiding behind numbers. Statistics are what kept him in control of his surroundings and prevented any surprises, stopping him from fully letting Hadley in.

Oliver Jones (Ben Hardy) and Hadley Sullivan (Haley Lu Richardson) attend her dad's wedding reception, in "Love at First Sight." (Rob Baker Ashton/Netflix)
Oliver Jones (Ben Hardy) and Hadley Sullivan (Haley Lu Richardson) attend her dad's wedding reception, in "Love at First Sight." Rob Baker Ashton/Netflix

It’s because they are different and find themselves in different situations that one of them has the key to unlocking the solution—which the other one doesn’t—and that they are able to connect and bring out something unique in each other. Hadley makes Oliver forget about the probability of falling in love at first sight, while he makes her realize that things can be good even if they don’t last.

“Love at First Sight” is a sweet little film, and due to the Christmas setting, a good watch for the holiday season. It’s one of the better romantic movies currently on Netflix.

Movie poster for "Love at First Sight."
Movie poster for "Love at First Sight."
‘Love at First Sight’ Director: Vanessa Caswill Starring: Haley Lu Richardson, Ben Hardy, Jameela Jamil, Rob Delaney, Sally Phillips, Tom Taylor MPAA Rating: PG-13 Running Time: 1 hour, 30 minutes Release Date: Sept. 15, 2023 Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars
Would you like to see other kinds of arts and culture articles? Please email us your story ideas or feedback at [email protected]
Mark Jackson
Mark Jackson
Film Critic
Mark Jackson is the chief film critic for the Epoch Times. In addition to film, he enjoys martial arts, motorcycles, rock-climbing, qigong, and human rights activism. Jackson earned a bachelor's degree in philosophy from Williams College, followed by 20 years' experience as a New York professional actor. He narrated The Epoch Times audiobook "How the Specter of Communism is Ruling Our World," available on iTunes, Audible, and YouTube. Mark is a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic.
Related Topics