Harmony and Hardship: Carl Maria von Weber and Tuberculosis

The German Romantic opera composer’s drive and musical creativity was not dampened by his deteriorating health.
Harmony and Hardship: Carl Maria von Weber and Tuberculosis
A portrait of composer Carl Maria von Weber. Public Domain
Updated:
0:00
Carl Maria von Weber is considered the founder of German romantic opera. He was not the first to write an opera in that language (Mozart preceded him), but he drew on uniquely German cultural themes as no one before him had. Though he died young, he left an indelible impact on those who came after him, particularly Richard Wagner.

Early Life and Success

Weber was born in 1786 in the town of Eutin, Germany, 20 miles north of Lübeck. His father was a musician and traveling actor, and young Carl first learned to play an instrument while traveling with the caravan. When his uncle, Fridolin, attempted to give Carl, age 3, a music lesson, Fridolin tore the bow from the boy’s little hands and said, “Whatever else may be made of you, you’ll never be a musician!”

Despite this, Weber soon showed a genius for music. He grew up to become accomplished in several areas, not only as a composer but as a conductor.

Carl Maria von Weber, 1814, painting by Thomas Lawrence. (Public Domain)
Carl Maria von Weber, 1814, painting by Thomas Lawrence. Public Domain

Before Weber’s time, conductors waved violin bows or rolled-up pieces of paper, or even pounded a staff on the floor to keep time. Breaking with this, Weber used a baton—though he held it in the middle, not on the end.

In addition to conducting, he was a great piano virtuoso. Whether waving a baton or playing the keys, he performed with great energy and exhibited a magnetic charisma on stage.

He composed many works, including pieces for the clarinet that are still performed regularly, but Weber’s most important contributions were to opera. The best-known of these today is “Der Freischütz.”

Premiering in 1821, Weber drew on the style of German folk songs in composing the opera. The story, about a hunter who sells his soul to the Devil in exchange for silver bullets that never miss, was enormously popular with theatergoers and became an international sensation.

The Romantic Disease

Weber was lame and suffered poor health as a child. This took a more drastic turn when, in 1812, he began developing the symptoms of tuberculosis. What started as “rheumatism” in the chest gradually worsened. In an age where the disease was not yet curable, or even known to be infectious, Weber placed an excessive trust in doctors and would often change treatments based on new opinions.

Tuberculosis, then known as “consumption,” has been called “the romantic disease.” Many important 19th-century artists suffered from it, including the Brontë sisters, Friedrich Schiller, and Anton Chekhov. Due to this association, there was a popular perception that the disease heightened creativity, functioning as a sort of morbid muse.

Weber took on this perception, taking pleasure in discussing his symptoms and even believing that he lived under the influence of an “evil star.” Though there is no medical evidence that tuberculosis sharpens compositional powers, belief can have a powerful influence on reality. Knowing his time might be limited, Weber strained himself through long hours of overwork which contributed to his deterioration.

Those who met Weber were fascinated by his combination of magnetism and sickliness. A 9-year old Richard Wagner, observing Weber conduct “Der Freischütz” in Dresden, left us this description:
“His fine, narrow face with its lively yet often heavily veiled eyes made a powerful impression on me; while his pronounced limp, which I often observed as he passed our window on his way home from exhausting rehearsals, impressed on my imagination the picture of the great musician as an exceptional superhuman being.”

A Final Opera

“Der Freischütz” became a sensation in London, sparking a “Weber craze.” Charles  Kemble, the manager of the Theatre Royal, Covent Garden, invited the composer to London to write and direct a new opera. As subjects, Kemble offered the choices of Faust (the German scholar who sold his soul to the devil) or Oberon (the fairy king best known from Shakespeare’s “A Midsummer Night’s Dream”). Weber settled on the subject of Oberon, and he took English lessons to prepare for his journey to England.
Lucia Elisabeth Vestris (née Bartolozzi) as Fatima in Carl Maria von Weber's opera "Oberon." (Public Domain)
Lucia Elisabeth Vestris (née Bartolozzi) as Fatima in Carl Maria von Weber's opera "Oberon." Public Domain

Uncharacteristically for Weber, he went against his doctor’s advice in accepting the commission, since he badly needed money. He threw himself into composition, and, after arriving in London, rehearsals and preparations took a further toll on his health.

Weber was greeted as a celebrity in London, where, in his first public appearance, he conducted the overture to “Der Freischütz” to great acclaim.

“Oberon, or The Elf-King’s Oath” premiered on April 12, 1826 to resounding success. Weber wrote his wife that when he stepped into the orchestra pit, he was met with “shouting, vivats and hurraying, waving of hats and handkerchiefs.” The overture was repeated, and three scenes in the opera were given encores. After it ended, there was “a storm of applause—such an honour as England has never before extended to a composer.”

For the next two months, Weber continued to lead sold-out performances of “Oberon” with his energetic conducting style. The effort destroyed his health. On May 26, he gave a final concert of a new song he had written, accompanying a soprano on the piano. It was his final public appearance before succumbing to tuberculosis on June 5, the day before he was to return to Germany.

Inventing the Leitmotif

The main story of “Oberon” drew inspiration less from Shakespeare than from the 1780 epic poem by Christoph Martin Wieland. The libretto, written by James Robinson Planché, was not very inspired. In the words of one of Weber’s biographers, John Warrack, the text is full of artificial dialogue, absurd plot details, and characters that are “mere stuffed costumes.”

In this respect, “Oberon” is comparable to Mozart’s “Magic Flute” (“Die Zauberflöte”), whose libretto by Emanuel Schikaneder has many weak points. Weber recognized Planché’s flaws as a writer and also disliked the abundance of spoken scenes, a characteristic of the English genre of semi-opera. But of Weber’s music, there is nothing to complain. “Oberon” is full of gems that transcend its shortcomings.

Although Richard Wagner is often credited with inventing recurring musical motives and themes, it was actually Weber who originated this. In “Oberon,” the title character’s horn serves a unifying dramatic function. The overture begins with the French horn playing a simple three-note “do-re-mi” motif in adagio (at a slow tempo). The string section answers this call, and the woodwinds enter to evoke a “fairy laughter” that sets the supernatural atmosphere for the drama. Throughout the work, Oberon’s horn is again played when characters face moments of danger.

This use of the leitmotif had a profound influence on the adult Wagner, who further developed the technique.

When Weber died, he left behind a 4-year-old son, Max, who would grow up to publish the first biography of his father. Max became a civil engineer rather than a composer, but his scholarly dedication helped keep his father’s memory alive.

Max Maria von Weber in 1879. (Public Domain)
Max Maria von Weber in 1879. Public Domain

Weber’s heroic struggle against terminal illness is an inspiration for all artists who face obstacles to realizing their creativity. His operas are a blessing to the world of classical music.

What arts and culture topics would you like us to cover? Please email ideas or feedback to [email protected]
Andrew Benson Brown
Andrew Benson Brown
Author
Andrew Benson Brown is a Missouri-based poet, journalist, and writing coach. He is an editor at Bard Owl Publishing and Communications and the author of “Legends of Liberty,” an epic poem about the American Revolution. For more information, visit Apollogist.wordpress.com.