Film Review: ‘No Hard Feelings’

Mark Jackson
Updated:

Why on God’s green earth did Jennifer Lawrence choose the low, low bar R-rated sex farce “No Hard Feelings” to do full-frontal nudity in is beyond me. A classy, artsy movie, ok, but a comedy about a 32-year-old woman who seduces a nerdy high school boy in order to get a Buick as payment from his helicopter parents, so he’ll be prepared for girls at Princeton? Where’s the discernment? This is Oscar-winner Jennifer Lawrence we’re talking about. Also Katniss in “Hunger Games.” She can’t need the money this badly.

Was she maybe convinced by the fact that the surface veneer of raunch hides a caramel-y, Hallmark-y heart that “redeems” it? Maybe the jokes looked good on the page, and since J-Law can do comedy with the best of the A-list actresses—she just couldn’t resist?

Regardless, she can’t save this clunker. But she could have conceivably suspected as much seeing as how director Gene Stupnitsky wrote this dreck with screenwriter John Phillips, the latter giving us the incredibly bad “Dirty Grandpa”—a career low for J-Law’s fellow Oscar winner, Robert De Niro.

Cougar

Maddie (Jennifer Lawrence) and a former flame (Ebon Moss-Bachrach) in "No Hard Feelings," (Columbia Pictures/Sony Pictures Releasing)
Maddie (Jennifer Lawrence) and a former flame (Ebon Moss-Bachrach) in "No Hard Feelings," Columbia Pictures/Sony Pictures Releasing

Maddie (Lawrence) is a Montauk, New York, Uber driver and bartender with lots of jilted ex-boyfriends, one of whom delightedly repossesses her car one fine morning. While trying to re-seduce said ex to get him to leave her car alone, in her bathrobe, a young Italian man comes out of her house in his Speedo underwear to do some stretching. She claims this is her cousin. Her bartender tips won’t pay the taxes on the house she inherited from her mother, so that’ll be the next thing to go.

Maddie (Jennifer Lawrence) rollerblading to an interview, in "No Hard Feelings." (Columbia Pictures/Sony Pictures Releasing)
Maddie (Jennifer Lawrence) rollerblading to an interview, in "No Hard Feelings." Columbia Pictures/Sony Pictures Releasing
Strapped for cash (and wheels) Maddie goes to an interview on rollerblades. Which interview? A Craigslist ad from a wealthy local couple (Matthew Broderick, Laura Benanti). As mentioned, they’re immensely worried about their socially awkward boy, Percy (Andrew Barth Feldman). They think they’re hiring a “sex worker” to “date” their 19-year-old in exchange for a car. Granted, the consensual limit in New York State is 17, but Percy presents as 15, so, you know—good stuff!
Obviously, young Percy is not informed as to the nature of his parents’ intentions. So when Maddie show up in a form-fitting hot pink dress at his dog-shelter job and comes on strong, ultimately coaxing him into the van she’s borrowed from her landscaping friend (which has gardening implements such as machetes hanging in the back), he’s terrified of being kidnapped and resorts to macing her in the kisser.
Maddie (Jennifer Lawrence), 32 years old, and the car she hopes to snag by dating a 19-year-old, in "No Hard Feelings." (Columbia Pictures/Sony Pictures Releasing)
Maddie (Jennifer Lawrence), 32 years old, and the car she hopes to snag by dating a 19-year-old, in "No Hard Feelings." Columbia Pictures/Sony Pictures Releasing

Wait, There’s More!

The film’s first swerve into schmaltz finds Percy and Maddie (both of whom never went to prom) dressing up to go to an upscale restaurant. And, per Percy’s parent’s hopes that she find ways to get him out of his shell,  insists that he go play the restaurant piano, where he unexpectedly sings the heck out of Hall and Oates’s “Maneater.” I bet you didn’t know that a cougar is a man-eating cat.

But at some point, Percy perceives her perfidious intentions, and hies himself to a teen party for snooty Princeton matriculators and commences his foray into the collegiate party life.

Knowing he’ll be no good at that whatsoever, Maddie comes to his rescue, whereupon the drunk Percy accidentally punches her in the neck. After which, we get the naked reconciliation moonlight skinny-dip where their clothes get stolen, and J-Law emerges like Venus on the half-shell to do naked beach barfighting and what appears to be naked jiu-jitsu, with the clothes thieves.

Maddie (Jennifer Lawrence) pretending to be overjoyed at the beer-drinking hat that the infatuated Percy (Andrew Barth Feldman) has bought her, in "No Hard Feelings." (Columbia Pictures/Sony Pictures Releasing)
Maddie (Jennifer Lawrence) pretending to be overjoyed at the beer-drinking hat that the infatuated Percy (Andrew Barth Feldman) has bought her, in "No Hard Feelings." Columbia Pictures/Sony Pictures Releasing

That’s Probably Enough Synopsis

Let’s put it this way—if I hadn’t been on the job, I’d have walked out. Right after Italian Speedo guy. Back in the day, Susan Sarandon’s Nora Baker in “White Palace,” and Jennifer Coolidge’s Stifler’s mom in “American Pie” cougars were fun. Granted, Anne Bancroft’s Mrs. Robinson from “The Graduate” was depressing to watch and she was cruel, but the film did reveal societal cracks and the problems with the sexual revolution.
Maddie (Jennifer Lawrence) and Percy (Andrew Barth Feldman), in "No Hard Feelings." (Columbia Pictures/Sony Pictures Releasing)
Maddie (Jennifer Lawrence) and Percy (Andrew Barth Feldman), in "No Hard Feelings." Columbia Pictures/Sony Pictures Releasing
Regardless of the fact that in this era of everyone’s feelings getting hurt all over the place, and drop-of-a-hat bully-policing, one might not fault audiences of “No Hard Feelings” for reaching for their phones to call child protective services on J-Law’s Maddie. Imagine a male movie star currently playing a prostitute, ... oh I’m sorry, “sex worker.” (I still have too much fun recalling Dan Akroyd’s line from the 1970s Saturday Night Live skit: “Because I’m Fred Garvin … male prostitute.”)

Where was I? Oh yeah: Can you imagine a male movie star currently playing a prostitute paid by parents to have sex with their virginal pubescent daughter? Even if it was funny, it would blow our collective minds. To borrow my last line from my “The Flash” review: “The global moral dye-vat darkens daily due to the deluge of demonic detritus.”

Movie poster for "No Hard Feelings," (Columbia Pictures/Sony Pictures Releasing)
Movie poster for "No Hard Feelings," Columbia Pictures/Sony Pictures Releasing
‘No Hard Feelings’ Director: Gene Stupnitsky Starring: Jennifer Lawrence, Andrew Barth Feldman, Matthew Broderick, Laura Benanti MPAA Rating: R Running Time: 1 hour, 43 minutes Release Date: June 23, 2023 Rating: 1.5 out of 5 stars
Mark Jackson
Mark Jackson
Film Critic
Mark Jackson is the chief film critic for the Epoch Times. In addition to film, he enjoys martial arts, motorcycles, rock-climbing, qigong, and human rights activism. Jackson earned a bachelor's degree in philosophy from Williams College, followed by 20 years' experience as a New York professional actor. He narrated The Epoch Times audiobook "How the Specter of Communism is Ruling Our World," available on iTunes, Audible, and YouTube. Mark is a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic.
Related Topics