TV Docuseries Review: ‘American Manhunt: The Boston Marathon Bombing’

Michael Clark
Updated:
TV-MA | 2h 57min | DocumentaryCrime, History | 12 April 2023 (USA)

While not nearly as deadly or widespread as the coordinated attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, the bombing of the Boston Marathon on April 15, 2013, nonetheless shook the nation to its core while reminding us that evil never rests; it only takes breaks.

As with 2001, the 2013 destruction was conceived and executed by Muslim extremists, only these weren’t Saudi nationals. They were two Kyrgyz-American brothers of Chechen descent raised in the very city they so wantonly terrorized.

A scene of chaos as a bomb goes off during the Boston Marathon on April 15, 2013 in "American Manhunt: The Boston Marathon Bombing." (Netflix)
A scene of chaos as a bomb goes off during the Boston Marathon on April 15, 2013 in "American Manhunt: The Boston Marathon Bombing." Netflix
Released nearly a decade to the day after the attack, the three-part Netflix docuseries “American Manhunt: The Boston Marathon Bombing” (“Manhunt”) does a fairly decent job of presenting the event itself while providing illuminating backstories of both victims and the perpetrators along with commentary from multiple legal and law enforcement individuals present at the time.

Mistaken Identity

Easily the most moving and impactful survivor testimony is delivered by Karen McWatters, an onlooker standing near the finish line waiting to welcome her marathon-running then-boyfriend Kevin. Both Karen and her friend Krystle Campbell were struck by projectiles discharged from the first of two pressure cooker bombs; Karen was mistakenly identified as Krystle by EMT responders because the former was in possession of the latter’s smartphone. Just how this mix-up was eventually sorted out is nothing short of heartbreaking.

The producers and series’ director Floyd Russ deserve high marks for devoting a hefty chunk of the second episode to the lesser-known plight of Dun “Danny” Meng. A Chinese national and the proud owner of a new Mercedes M-Class SUV, Meng was in the wrong place at the wrong time.

Shortly after murdering MIT police officer Sean Collier during a botched attempt to steal his sidearm, bomber brothers Tamerlan and Dzhokhar Tsarnaev trapped Meng, stole his vehicle, and took him hostage.

Dim Bulbs

Forcing Meng at gunpoint to make a withdrawal from an ATM, the brothers told him that they were indeed the ones responsible for the bombing and were headed to Times Square to do it again. This was just one of several things the Tsarnaev’s did and said that would lead anyone with half a clue to conclude: These were two of the most ill-prepared, dim-bulb mass murderers in the history of the planet.

In addition to not using any kind of disguise while placing their bombs (something which made identifying them via security video relatively easy), the Tsarnaevs, instead of fleeing, remained in Boston, thus increasing the odds they would be caught.

Brothers Dzhokhar (L) and Tamerlan (R) Tsarnaev are shown watching the Boston Marathon in “American Manhunt.” (Netflix)
Brothers Dzhokhar (L) and Tamerlan (R) Tsarnaev are shown watching the Boston Marathon in “American Manhunt.” Netflix
Murdering a cop in cold blood and carjacking a civilian only added insult to injury and these actions weren’t even their biggest faux pas. After all this, they drove to the tiny hamlet of Watertown, a city just over four-square miles in size with a dense population of well over 30,000.

Not Exactly Straight-Shooters

As it turns out, the Tsarnaevs weren’t the only ones not playing their “A-game” the night they were identified. One would rightfully think that well over 100 law-enforcement officers working for six police agencies firing 300 rounds in seven minutes at two stationary suspects might result in killing or at least disabling the suspects, but that wasn’t the case. The officer’s errant marksmanship resulted in dozens of rounds hitting and entering civilian homes with one bullet coming within three inches of a sleeping infant’s head.

Despite all of this manpower and discharged ammunition, one of the brothers managed to elude capture in the Mercedes and, while doing so, ran over the other brother and dragged him down the street, ultimately resulting in his death.

Not to make light of an extremely sad and dark event in U.S. history, but the entire Watertown fiasco played out like an installment of a “Keystone Kops” silent film from the early 20th century.

More Doesn’t Equal Better

One of, if not the most important duty of a documentary filmmaker isn’t in gathering and assembling footage, but rather presenting it in an efficient, streamlined manner. Given that the Boston Marathon Bombing was a heavily chronicled, relatively recent event, there was more than enough raw material with which to work. It is with the interview portions where Russ loses control of the narrative while making, as they say in sports, multiple “unforced errors.”

Including concise, expert talking head commentary analysis is great, but too much of it is not. Here, “too much” means one or more interviewees making the same observation or worse, a single interviewee making the same point with slightly different verbiage; repeating something doesn’t increase its impact.

Had Russ delivered a two-hour movie instead of a nearly three-hour docuseries, “Manhunt” would have packed a far greater wallop.

The three-part Netflix docuseries “American Manhunt: The Boston Marathon Bombing” (“Manhunt”) presents the event itself while providing illuminating back-stories. (Netflix)
The three-part Netflix docuseries “American Manhunt: The Boston Marathon Bombing” (“Manhunt”) presents the event itself while providing illuminating back-stories. Netflix
‘American Manhunt: The Boston Marathon Bombing’ Documentary Director: Floyd Russ Running time: 2 hours, 57 minutes MPAA Rating: TV-MA Release Date: April 12, 2023 Rating: 3 out of 5
Michael Clark
Michael Clark
Author
Originally from the nation's capital, Michael Clark has provided film content to over 30 print and online media outlets. He co-founded the Atlanta Film Critics Circle in 2017 and is a weekly contributor to the Shannon Burke Show on FloridaManRadio.com. Since 1995, Clark has written over 5,000 movie reviews and film-related articles. He favors dark comedy, thrillers, and documentaries.
Related Topics