Titian’s ‘Ecce Homo’ Asks Viewers to Weigh Their Faith

“Ecce Homo,” 1543, by Titian. Oil on canvas. Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna. Public Domain

During the early Renaissance, Ecce Homo became a popular theme in Christian art—particularly by Dutch masters. Usually translated as “Behold (ecce) the Man (homo),” it’s the standard term for artistic depictions of Christ being presented to his accusers after he has been scourged and crowned with thorns. Latin has a more nuanced connotation. Speaking precisely, “homo” translates as adult male. But it can also emphasize ordinariness.

The scene where Christ’s death was demanded by a hostile crowd (Luke 23:13–25; John 19:13–16) was rarely painted by Italian artists before the 17th century. In 1543, Venetian Renaissance painter Titian (circa 1488–1576) composed an early interpretation of the scene for the Flemish merchant Giovanni d’Anna, which explains the unusual subject choice for the Italian artist.

Titian’s “Ecce Homo” moves the viewer’s eye up the staircase to the figure of Christ. Although Jesus is placed at the edge of the canvas, he becomes the composition’s central focus.

Titian’s brilliant staging, expressive color, and sensitive renderings of portraits and objects inspired later generations of European artists. By placing the viewer among the crowd, Titian is likewise asking his audience to weigh their conscience and faith.

Titian’s Composition

Detail of figures: Christ, Pontius Pilate, guard, and priest in “Ecce Homo,” 1543, by Titian. Public Domain

A few figures are particularly prominent in Titian’s “Ecce Homo”: an officer of the Jewish Temple guards, a priest, and Pontius Pilate. The officer—one of those who arrested Jesus in the garden of Gethsemane—stands on the stairs in the center of the composition. His status is indicated by the deep maroon clothing and halberd (polearm with ax and spike). At the foot of the staircase is the priest, wearing a white and gold robe, a long red cloak, and an ermine mozzetta (elbow length cape). Similarities between his garments and papal attire suggest that Titian may have intended the figure to be the high priest Caiaphas.

Both figures frame a woman whose blonde hair and white dress present a vivid contrast to the rest of the crowd. Dressed in a color traditionally signifying purity, she nevertheless is among those demanding Christ’s death.

Surrounding these figures are members of the Judean elite. Three men in dark armor and one in rich black and white attire are notable. Viewed as a whole, the crowd gains added visual prominence through contrast with the sky in the background.

Moving up the stairs, the next figure is Pontius Pilate—standing out in bright blue against the neutral covered stone of the praetorium. The model for him was Pietro Aretino, a friend of Titian and probably a symbolic choice. As a prominent writer of the day, Aretino argued that Pilate was a generally decent man in his book “The Humanity of Christ.” He based his case on the fact that Pilate tried to save Christ’s life before surrendering to mob pressure. Whether the choice to paint Aretino as Pilate was Titian’s own or that of his patron, D’Anna, is unclear.

A portrait of Pietro Aretino, 1537, by Titian. Oil on canvas; 40 1/8 inches by 33 3/4 inches. Henry Clay Frick Bequest, The Frick Collection, New York City. Pontius Pilate was modeled after Titian's friend and prominent writer Aretino. Public Domain

‘Behold the Lamb of God’

At the top left is Christ himself—his skin tone, almost blending in with the praetorium. By painting him at the top of the stairs, Titian literally positions Christ as the son of God above his enemies.

“Ecce Homo,” 1543, by Titian. Oil on canvas; 95 1/5 inches by 141 3/5 inches. Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna. Public Domain

In Christian theology, Christ’s death as a sacrifice to save sinners was prophetically foreshadowed by the sacrifice of Passover lambs. When an angel “passed over” Egypt to free the enslaved Hebrews, anyone in a house marked with the blood of the sacrificial lambs lived. All the firstborns in unmarked Egyptian houses died. From then until the Jerusalem Temple was destroyed in A.D. 70, lambs were sacrificed annually as part of Passover celebrations—and Christ himself was crucified at Passover.

This symbolism is heightened by the contrast between the painting’s title ‘‘Ecce Homo” and a similar phrase that Titian’s contemporaries knew well, “Ecce Agnus Dei, ecce qui tollit peccata mundi” (Behold the Lamb of God, behold he who takes away the sins of the world). An allusion to the Passover lambs applied to Christ by John the Baptist in John 1:29, it is repeated by Catholic priests before distributing communion. Titian’s Catholic contemporaries would have easily recognized this symbolism.

In Titian’s painting, he expanded on the symbolism of Christ’s sacrificial death by the way he painted the figures’ clothing. Christ, Pilate, and a Roman soldier wear clothing typical of circa A.D. 30 Judea. But the crowd wears clothing from Renaissance Europe. This isn’t just a generic allusion to the people of Titian’s time—or even to its prominent soldiers, knights, and nobility. Including a pope-like figure and a woman in white points to even the highest clergymen and the almost perfectly pure people of Titian’s day sharing responsibility for the crucifixion through their own sins.

A detail of the soldier in “Ecce Homo,” 1543, by Titian. Public Domain

At the bottom left is a soldier whose shield is decorated with black double eagles—symbol of the Holy Roman Empire that was ruled by Titian’s most important patron, Charles V (1500–1558). Charles V was the Holy Roman emperor of the German nation and Archduke of Austria from 1519 to 1521, King of Spain from 1516 to 1556, and Duke of Burgundy from 1506 to 1555. It’s  possible that the painting’s patron Giovanni d’Anna—being Lord of the Netherlands—wanted to stress that his own family were subjects of Charles V or show some deference to the emperor.

Appropriately enough, Titian’s “Ecce Homo” now hangs in the Vienna Museum of Art History. Founded by Emperor Franz Josef I in the late 19th century, the museum allows the public access to view the imperial family’s magnificent art collection.

What arts and culture topics would you like us to cover? Please email ideas or feedback to [email protected]