‘Titanic The Musical’

This spellbinding musical dramatizes the tragedy of the RMS Titanic, the world’s first supposedly ‘unsinkable’ ship.
‘Titanic The Musical’
The cast of "Titanic The Musical." Justin Barbin Photography
Updated:
0:00

LINICOLNSHIRE, Ill.—It was supposed to be unsinkable, so when the Titanic hit an iceberg and sank into the icy waters of the Atlantic Ocean, the horrific disaster became the stuff of legend. Now it’s playing in a spectacular production at the Marriott Theatre in Lincolnshire, Illinois.

Like the films “A Night to Remember” in 1958 and “Titanic” in 1997, and a stunning Broadway musical in 1997, this production is based on the April 15, 1912 tragedy in which the RMS Titanic struck an iceberg and sank. Approximately 1,500 passengers perished. The ship left Southhampton, England, and was on its way to New York City when the unthinkable occurred.

A Tragedy Dramatized

The remnants of the sunken ship were discovered off the coast of Newfoundland in 1985. It ignited cultural interest in the ship and its history. The artifacts found in the wreckage inspired Maury Yeston to compose a stage production. He believed that humanity’s attempt to build the Titanic, a technological wonder of its time, was the stuff of dreams and worthy of staging. He persuaded Peter Stone to write a libretto for the show, which opened on Broadway in April 1997 and won five Tony Awards.
(L–R) Laura Guley, Erica Stephan, and Victoria Okafor in "Titanic The Musical." (Justin Barbin Photography)
(L–R) Laura Guley, Erica Stephan, and Victoria Okafor in "Titanic The Musical." Justin Barbin Photography

Although the harrowing story of the doomed ship remains the same as that of the 1997 film, the big difference between the silver screen presentation and the Marriott’s production is in its main characterization. While the James Cameron film featured the fictional characters of Jack (Leonardo DiCaprio) and Rose (Kate Winslet) as lovers on the ill-fated voyage, the musical is based on the real-life people aboard the ship.

J. Bruce Ismay (Adam Pelty) must rise to the occasion, in "Titanic The Musical." (Justin Barbin Photography)
J. Bruce Ismay (Adam Pelty) must rise to the occasion, in "Titanic The Musical." Justin Barbin Photography

While the original Broadway production had a large scenic design and a full orchestra, the Marriott production has been scaled down to more modest dimensions. It has a small orchestra and an ensemble half the size of the original 43 performers. These modifications make the musical more intimate and heartwarming without robbing any of its power.

Indeed, the show, which was mounted in celebration of the Marriott’s 50th anniversary, is as spectacular and stunning as the story it tells. Masterfully directed and choreographed by Connor Gallagher, and with Ryan T. Nelson’s musical direction, the show is mesmerizing.

Edgar Beane (James Earl Jones II) and Alice Beane (Lillian Castillo), in "Titanic The Musical." (Justin Barbin Photography)
Edgar Beane (James Earl Jones II) and Alice Beane (Lillian Castillo), in "Titanic The Musical." Justin Barbin Photography

While working on Marriott’s theater-in-the-round may be more challenging than a typical proscenium stage, scenic designer Collette Pollard does an extraordinary job of creating the feel of a large seafaring vessel. Jesse Klug’s lighting with Michael Daly’s sound design creates a spellbinding atmosphere of tension and suspense. The combination of those artistic talents delivers an amazing, breathtaking atmosphere of a ship taking on water and twisting on its side.

The multi-sided stage provides ample opportunities for the cast to create a more authentic "ship-like" experience. (Justin Barbin Photography)
The multi-sided stage provides ample opportunities for the cast to create a more authentic "ship-like" experience. Justin Barbin Photography

Many in the cast of 21 play more than one role. These superb actors  grab our attention and our heartfelt empathy. In the featured role of Capt. Smith, David Girolmo, one of Chicago’s most gifted performers, is riveting. Other compelling portrayals include Adam Pelty as J. Bruce Ismay, Darian Goulding as Benjamin Guggenheim, Heidi Kettenring as Ida Straus, Mark David Kaplan as her husband Isidor Straus, Erica Stephan as Kate McGowan, and Charles Lightoller as John Jacob Astor.

Ida Straus (Heidi Kettenring) clasps hands with her husband Isidor Straus (Mark David Kaplan) on the ill-fated Titanic, in "Titanic The Musical." (Justin Barbin Photography)
Ida Straus (Heidi Kettenring) clasps hands with her husband Isidor Straus (Mark David Kaplan) on the ill-fated Titanic, in "Titanic The Musical." Justin Barbin Photography

The period costumes by Sully Ratke with wigs and makeup by Miguel A. Armstrong give a strong impression of the class differences between upper level and lower level passengers, as well as a terrific feel for the early 20th century.

The performers aren’t just in top acting form. They also deliver wonderful vocalizations of Yeston’s many beautiful and haunting melodies. While most musicals feature a few good tunes, this “Titanic” provides over a dozen musical numbers that will move audiences to emotion and even tears. Among them are memorable songs, including “What a Remarkable Age This Is,” “To Be a Captain,” “The Night was Alive,” “Doing the Latest Rag,” “The Blame,” “Autumn,” “We’ll Meet Tomorrow,” and the poignant “Godspeed Titanic.”

Kate McGowan (Erica Stephan) talks with Jim Farrell (Garrett Lutz), in "Titanic The Musical." (Justin Barbin Photography)
Kate McGowan (Erica Stephan) talks with Jim Farrell (Garrett Lutz), in "Titanic The Musical." Justin Barbin Photography

Although this popular musical production was a big hit on Broadway, theater companies rarely mount “Titanic The Musical.” The spectacular show makes huge demands on artistic talent. It’s also so costly to produce that only deep pockets can consider presenting it. That the Marriott has mounted the show is an exemplary theatrical achievement. The fact that it is such an awesome, passionate presentation makes it even more credit-worthy.

The cast of "Titanic The Musical" emphasize how the event was an unprecedented tragedy. (Justin Barbin Photography)
The cast of "Titanic The Musical" emphasize how the event was an unprecedented tragedy. Justin Barbin Photography

This is a show that only comes around once in a great while. Rush to see it while you can!

‘Titanic The Musical’ Marriott Theatre 10 Marriott Drive, Lincolnshire, Ill. Tickets: 847-634-0200 or www.MarriottTheatre.com Runs: 2 hours, 20 minutes (one intermission) Closes: June 1, 2025
What arts and culture topics would you like us to cover? Please email ideas or feedback to [email protected]
Betty Mohr
Betty Mohr
Author
As an arts writer and movie/theater/opera critic, Betty Mohr has been published in the Chicago Sun-Times, The Chicago Tribune, The Australian, The Dramatist, the SouthtownStar, the Post Tribune, The Herald News, The Globe and Mail in Toronto, and other publications.