‘The Screwtape Letters’: C.S. Lewis’s Satirical Theology

The demon Screwtape has a sophisticated understanding of human nature and a ruthless commitment to undermining it in this classic read.
‘The Screwtape Letters’: C.S. Lewis’s Satirical Theology
"The Screwtape Letters," by C.S. Lewis.
6/17/2024
Updated:
6/17/2024
0:00

C.S. Lewis was a towering figure in 20th century literature, renowned for his contributions to both fiction and Christian apologetics. Best known for “The Chronicles of Narnia,” Lewis’s works transcend genre boundaries, offering insights into human nature and spirituality.

The Screwtape Letters,” first published in 1942, differs from conventional narratives that modern readers might be used to. The novel consists of a series of letters penned by a senior demon to a younger demon, guiding him on the best ways to get a human being to damn himself.

The epistolary format allows Lewis to explore complex themes of temptation, moral struggle, and the human condition. Through Screwtape’s infernal instructions to his minion, Lewis provides readers with a mirror to examine their own spiritual lives.

The demon Screwtape teaches an inexperienced demon nephew how to tempt humans and lead them to hell in this classic novel. (Triff/Shutterstock)
The demon Screwtape teaches an inexperienced demon nephew how to tempt humans and lead them to hell in this classic novel. (Triff/Shutterstock)

Spirituality Through Humor

“The Screwtape Letters” unfolds through a progression of 31 short letters from Screwtape to his nephew Wormwood, who is tasked with securing the damnation of a nameless young man.
Screwtape’s advice ranges from encouraging mundane distractions, since “mortals always picture us as putting things into their minds. ... (O)ur best work is done by keeping things out, to exploiting deep-seated vices.  ... [God] has this curious fantasy of making all these disgusting human vermin into what He calls His ‘free’ lovers and servants … and here lies our opportunity.” This illustrates how people can be diverted from a pathway toward the divine.
The novel is set against the backdrop of World War II, a timely choice that enriches its themes by juxtaposing personal moral battles with global conflict. This historical context grounds the narrative in a time of widespread uncertainty and fear but also parallels the internal struggles faced by individuals amidst external chaos.

Characters

“The Screwtape Letters” is laced with the senior demon’s cunning and manipulative insights and strategies. It quickly becomes apparent that Screwtape has a sophisticated understanding of human nature and a ruthless commitment to undermining it. His tone is condescending yet authoritative, drawing on a lifetime of experiences and bottomless cynicism.
"The Temptation of St. Anthony," 1640, by David Teniers the Younger. Demons have tempted people for a long time. (Public Domain)
"The Temptation of St. Anthony," 1640, by David Teniers the Younger. Demons have tempted people for a long time. (Public Domain)

In contrast, Wormwood is portrayed as a clumsy and inexperienced demon, eager but mistake-prone in the art of temptation.

Interestingly, Lewis chooses not to show any of the letters Wormwood writes. This is a clever choice because it avoids repeating the problems Wormwood encounters in his damnation quest and skips right to the various strategies his uncle suggests to overcome the “Enemy” (how they refer to God).

Each chapter/letter recounts young Wormwood’s missteps, fumblings, and misunderstandings, enabling us to jump right into the ways and means of spiritual corruption.

The man that Wormwood is trying to lead astray is only referred to as “the patient.” The demons’ attitude toward humans is distant and detached, devoid of any personalization. They care nothing for humans. We are merely commodities, pawns in a tug-of-war with God for our souls. Each piece of correspondence lets readers follow the spiritual progress of the patient, and view his own tenuous connections with God through the lens of those seeking to destroy it.

Brilliant Satire

The real genius of “The Screwtape Letters” is its use of satire. At first glance, it seems very odd that the story’s so-called “heroes” are the devilish ones doing all the talking happen to be the most evil beings in existence.

Yet this perspective liberates the author to freely critique different aspects of faith and the faithful. For example, Screwtape questions his nephew if the patient has qualms with his church because of his indifference, this being a model reason for a human’s dissatisfaction with his house of worship.

“The Temptation of Saint Anthony, 1487–88, by a young Michelangelo, copying Martin Schongauer’s engraving. (Public Domain) Demons have a used a myriad of ways to tempt people.
“The Temptation of Saint Anthony, 1487–88, by a young Michelangelo, copying Martin Schongauer’s engraving. (Public Domain) Demons have a used a myriad of ways to tempt people.

Screwtape advises Wormwood that, if he can’t stop the man from going to church in the first place, he should at least encourage him to go “all over the neighborhood looking for the church that ‘suits’ him,” thus turning him into “a taster or connoisseur of churches.”

Screwtape’s language and tone is itself a cleverly disguised satire of the reasonable, logical, self-superior aristocratic caste of England. These are the world leaders of the time, or indeed any time, who view the various earthly horrors and holocausts of mankind with an attitude of bureaucratic banality.

God: Demons’ Ultimate Enemy

At the core of the novel are profound theological messages and the battle between good and evil. Temptation is presented not as overt evil but as subtle manipulations and distortions of truth, emphasizing how easily one can be led off a righteous path. The humor and wit are infused throughout the book and play a central role in its appeal.

By using the demon Screwtape as the narrator, Lewis cleverly inverts the traditional moral framework, making readers see their own flaws and temptations through a satirical lens.

The book’s appeal extends beyond religious circles, attracting readers who appreciate its clever use of mockery and caricature, as well as its exploration of universal moral dilemmas.

The novel’s impact is further evidenced by its numerous adaptations. “Screwtape Proposes a Toast,” a sequel in the form of an after-dinner speech by Screwtape. There’s also a stage adaptation that brings its natural “theater of absurd” format to audiences in new and engaging ways.

“The Screwtape Letters” is a must-read for its exceptional blend of entertainment and insightful exploration of spiritual themes. For newer readers, the book can be a fresh and engaging approach to discussing profound theological concepts, making it both thought-provoking and enjoyable.

Whether you are a long-time admirer of Lewis or new to his works, “The Screwtape Letters” offers a rich literary experience that will leave you reflecting on your own spiritual journey.

‘The Screwtape Letters’ By C.S. Lewis HarperOne, Feb. 6, 2001 Paperback:‎ 224 pages
Would you like to see other kinds of arts and culture articles? Please email us your story ideas or feedback at [email protected]
Freedom Chevalier is an award-winning, best-selling ghostwriter, author, and former journalist. Connect with her at ChevalierCreates.com