The Dutch Americans in the Midwest

A group of Dutch settlers in the 19th century paved the way for strong values and family ties in the land of opportunity.
The Dutch Americans in the Midwest
Typical Dutch homestead in Northeast Wisconsin, circa 1855. Public Domain
Updated:
0:00

Dutch Americans have a reputation for being an industrious people with a strong work ethic. From dairy farming to tulip growing to furniture manufacturing, they have dominated numerous industries.

They also boast robust religious and family values. How has this group of people achieved high material success while maintaining a strong cultural identity? Historically, there are two main factors: one tragically accidental, the other brilliantly deliberate.

The First Potato Famine

Immigration from the Netherlands began early in colonial American history. This occurred most notably in New York, where industrious merchants populated Manhattan and laid the foundations for the city that is now the financial capital of the world.

It was not until the 19th century, though, that Dutch immigration became a wave. The spur was an agricultural disaster in the 1840s known as the Dutch Potato Famine. Though it did not occur on as wide a scale as the Irish famine, it still resulted in about 50,000 deaths.

Poor people, unable to afford luxuries like pork, beef, or even wheaten bread, relied on the nutritious potato as the main ingredient for most of their meals. For many farmers throughout Europe, this crop was life.

When a fungus-like micro-organism known as Phytophthora infestans began turning potatoes black in the Netherlands, those who did not starve left in search of more promising opportunities.

A potato infected with late blight, showing typical rot symptoms. (Public Domain)
A potato infected with late blight, showing typical rot symptoms. Public Domain

The easiest way to trace the origins of Dutch settlements today is to look at the names of places. The Midwest is full of these designations. “Holland” naturally predominates: Holland, Michigan; South Holland, Illinois; New Holland, Illinois. Other names like Vriesland, Noordeloos, Delft, and Zeeland also betray their roots.

Why did the Dutch choose to settle in the Midwest, rather than elsewhere? Partly because land was cheap. Unlike the populous East Coast, it was also more isolated there, allowing them to preserve cultural traditions without outside interference.

A Short Man With a Big Vision

Famine was not the only reason for leaving the Netherlands. As with the earlier English Puritans, many the Dutch came to American shores to escape religious persecution. One clergyman named Albertus van Raalte, a man who stood at only 5 feet 3 inches but commanded much respect, took a systematic approach to ensure no traveler would be rootless.
Albertus van Raalte was a 19th-century pastor. He led the Dutch immigrants who founded the city of Holland, Michigan in 1846 and established the school that would become Hope College. (Public Domain)
Albertus van Raalte was a 19th-century pastor. He led the Dutch immigrants who founded the city of Holland, Michigan in 1846 and established the school that would become Hope College. Public Domain

His mission was to form a colony that allowed for freedom of worship and economic opportunity. He considered every problem of emigration, even drawing up a constitution titled “Rules for the Society of Christians for the Holland Emigration to the United States of North America.”

This governing document would apply to two communities: one operating in the Netherlands, and one in America. Local individuals and churches donated money to purchase land and help immigrants too poor to pay their way. All men 20 years and older were eligible for membership and were obliged to work the land at least two days each year.

In 1846, Van Raalte and 100 emigrants set sail for New York. Another 900 would follow the next year. Paying $1.25 per acre, Van Raalte purchased a large tract of land in Western Michigan and founded the town of Holland.

Like the Puritans, the Dutch faced many challenges in the colony’s early years—from bad harvests to learning the perplexing syntax of the English language. Under Van Raalte’s spiritual leadership, though, the community thrived and branched out to other settlements. He established the First Reformed Church of Holland. To educate the children of the colonists, he also laid the groundwork for what would become Hope College.

Thanks to these efforts, Dutch immigrants were able to transplant their cultural traditions in a new land and settle successfully without the same level of struggle and hardship that other groups, like the Irish, faced. Villages centered around church spires began to spring up throughout the Midwest.

The prospect of marriage and family life was also a big draw for Dutch immigrants. Women could find plenty of eligible young men who earned a good income to provide for them and raise a family. These opportunities, combined with strong religious values, meant that families provided the basis for the success of these communities.

Finding Success in Industry

By the early 20th century, Holland, Michigan boasted a number of successful businesses. Among these were furniture manufacturers, a pickle factory, a furnace company, and tourist resorts. Most famously, it began a major center for tulip cultivation and started an annual festival, Tulip Time, that is held to this day.
A windmill from the Netherlands stands behind a field of tulips in Holland, Michigan. (Craig Sterken/Shutterstock)
A windmill from the Netherlands stands behind a field of tulips in Holland, Michigan. Craig Sterken/Shutterstock

Elsewhere, other Dutch communities found successful niches in the economy. Kalamazoo, Michigan, became known as “The Paper City” for its contribution to this sector. For similar reasons, Grand Rapids was called “Furniture City.”

In the 1920s, immigrants to California modernized the dairy industry. Women were particularly drawn to dairy work, since making cheese and butter could improve a family’s livelihood, allowing for higher status than agricultural labor. In the past several decades, dairy farmers from the Netherlands have relocated to America, seeking cheaper land and more production opportunities.

Dutch Americans today still emphasize education, just as Albertus van Raalte once did. They are particularly prominent in the humanities, where they have tended to go into professions such as the ministry and university teaching. More technical fields like medicine, engineering, and contracting are also occupations they pursue. This love of learning no doubt contributes to their strong character already nurtured by religious beliefs, family values, and entrepreneurship. The Dutch American community continues to build on a proud legacy of success and fulfillment.

What arts and culture topics would you like us to cover? Please email ideas or feedback to [email protected]
Andrew Benson Brown
Andrew Benson Brown
Author
Andrew Benson Brown is a Missouri-based poet, journalist, and writing coach. He is an editor at Bard Owl Publishing and Communications and the author of “Legends of Liberty,” an epic poem about the American Revolution. For more information, visit Apollogist.wordpress.com.