‘Best Kept Secret’: JFK High School for Those With Special Needs

This installment of Movies for Teens and Young Adults is about customized care for those who need it.
‘Best Kept Secret’: JFK High School for Those With Special Needs
(L–R) Director Samantha Buck, producer Danielle DiGiacomo, and teacher Janet Mino at the world premiere of "Best Kept Secret" Boston International Film Festival in 2013. Tim Pierce/CC BY-SA 3.0
Updated:
0:00
For over 18 months, documentary filmmakers followed the journey of Janet Mino, a New Jersey special education teacher at JFK High School. She lovingly prepared her batch of young adults with special needs for graduation in 2012. Families, guardians, and care and education professionals call aging out of the school system “falling off the cliff” because of how vulnerable graduates are when they strike out on their own.
The film “Best Kept Secret” (2013), dwells on Mino’s classroom, but tells a wider tale of heroism. It shows teachers, administrators, and social workers working far beyond the call of duty, and showing extraordinary empathy toward people who are otherwise misunderstood, mistreated, or mocked. Click here for plot summary, cast, reviews, and ratings.
Samantha Buck, director of "Best Kept Secret." (CC BY-SA 2 0)
Samantha Buck, director of "Best Kept Secret." CC BY-SA 2 0
Director Samantha Buck opens her film with the school’s telephone operator answering a caller with a curious greeting, “Thank you for calling John F. Kennedy, best kept secret in the North Public Schools. How may I help you?” Buck’s introductory text explains why it’s a secret. One in four young people in New Jersey is autistic, the highest incidence in America and, for over 40 years, JFK High School has offered a public education to such students aged 10 to 21. The film focuses on Mino’s journey with three students, Quran, Eric, and Robert, who each show varying levels of progress.

Independent Students

Mino, who’s been teaching for over two decades, explains that she’s not a doctor and she’s not looking for a cure. But she’s trying her best to get her students to care for themselves and express themselves so they can function better and relatively independently in the real world.

She’s warm, patient, and gentle, but firm. If they aren’t loud and clear enough when asking or answering questions, they can’t make others understand what they need, let alone get them to meet those needs. If they don’t overcome their fears—one student overcomes his fear of plants—they’ll struggle to function normally, let alone learn work skills, then find and hold onto jobs. She insists on, but doesn’t always find, empathetic job coaches who’ll help students ease into jobs, whether that means cleaning floors and pews at a church, or a job at Burger King.

Mino’s spontaneous laughter and her smile of contentment when she’s with her students belies her resolve to find them meaningful futures. Her meetings with bridge programs, such as the Wellness, Arts, Enrichment (WAE) Center or Pathways for Independence, and federal or state programs like the Division for Vocational Rehab, have mixed results.

As graduation day nears, you see her growing anxieties around solutions that involve her wards in robotic, factory-like jobs; these choke their chances to practice the communication and connection skills they continually need to strengthen self-confidence and self-belief. Mino resents solutions that put them only in large groups, not one-on-one settings. She wants the best for them even after they graduate. It’s up to a social worker to tell her compassionately but insistently, “They may or may not regress but you have to let … go.”

Buck shows how vital parents are to this journey. A student’s father explains that once he accepted that it was up to him to understand his autistic son—not the other way around—he could better complement at home what teachers did at school.

The poster for "Best Kept Secret."
The poster for "Best Kept Secret."

When his mother drops by, the otherwise quiet Eric excitedly kisses her and smilingly chatters. Moved, Mino tells her, “You gotta come more often. We get more language out of him.”

Buck’s camera captures a classroom poster that embodies what teachers explicitly tell their students: that they are responsible for their actions. What’s implicit? They aren’t responsible for the indifferent or disrespectful way some people treat them. Another poster says, “This is a positive thinking area.” What’s implicit? They'll face more than their share of negative thinking in areas outside their classroom.

Of course, graduates still require special help even after graduating, but without a consistently protective school system, their struggle to overcome their disabilities may overwhelm them and their families. Buck’s film goes a long way in saluting and celebrating brave hearts like Mino who customize care for those who need it.

Addressing proud families on graduation day, JFK Principal Dr. Johnson Green thunders, “You must always advocate for your children and fight for what … they deserve. Do not sit back and let anyone tell you what they cannot do. We ... thrive on ... their abilities, not … their disabilities.”

You can watch “Best Kept Secret” on Hoopla, Tubi,  Apple TV, and Prime Video.
These reflective articles may interest parents, caretakers, or educators of teenagers and young adults, seeking great movies to watch together or recommend. They’re about films that, when viewed thoughtfully, nudge young people to be better versions of themselves.
What arts and culture topics would you like us to cover? Please email ideas or feedback to [email protected]
Rudolph Lambert Fernandez
Rudolph Lambert Fernandez
Author
Rudolph Lambert Fernandez is an independent writer who writes on pop culture.
twitter