Belle da Costa Greene: The Morgan Library’s Medieval Manuscripts

The Morgan Library & Museum celebrates its inaugural director and her selection of superlative medieval manuscripts.
Belle da Costa Greene: The Morgan Library’s Medieval Manuscripts
A copy of St. Beatus of Liébana's “Commentary on the Apocalypse,” circa 945, by San Salvador de Tábara, Spain. Among the greatest medieval Spanish illuminations, the manuscript was acquired by Belle da Costa Greene for the Morgan Library in 1919. Courtesy of The Morgan Library & Museum
Updated:
0:00

The Morgan Library & Museum in New York City is renowned for its world-class collection of medieval illuminated manuscripts. The funds for amassing these works came from the banking and industrial fortunes of J.P. Morgan and, after his death, his son. But the mastermind behind the acquisitions was Belle da Costa Greene—a pioneering librarian in taste, knowledge, and biography.

Greene’s contribution to the museum is being celebrated in The Morgan’s special exhibition “Belle da Costa Greene: A Librarian’s Legacy,” on view through May 4. It marks the library’s centenary as a public institution, and a highlight of the show is the selection of superlative medieval manuscripts on display.

Morgan’s Mastermind

A portrait of Belle da Costa Greene, 1910, by Ernest Walter Histed. (Courtesy of The Morgan Library & Museum)
A portrait of Belle da Costa Greene, 1910, by Ernest Walter Histed. Courtesy of The Morgan Library & Museum

Belle da Costa Greene (1879–1950) was the inaugural director of the library. She was born in Washington and was originally known as Belle Marion Greener. Her father, Richard T. Greener, graduated from Harvard College and became a notable scholar and diplomat. After her parents separated, Belle’s mother changed their surname to Greene and the family began to pass as white. Belle would later add “da Costa” to strengthen her claim of Portuguese ancestry. Her African American heritage was largely unknown during her lifetime.

Erudite and visionary, Greene was hired by Morgan Sr. as his personal librarian in 1905. He died eight years later. Throughout his collecting career, he acquired around 600 manuscripts. Greene continued to work for his heir, J.P. Morgan Jr., who went on to purchase 200 manuscripts with Greene’s guidance. Upon the creation of the public Pierpont Morgan Library in 1924, Greene became director and remained in the role for 24 years. During her entire tenure, she was instrumental in the purchase and management of manuscripts, rare books, and fine art.
Greene’s scholastic specialty was illuminated manuscripts. She had ambitious plans for Morgan Sr.’s collection, and in a 1909 letter to him, she wrote: “I have bought other books to fill gaps—one aim is to make the Library preeminent, especially for incunabula, manuscripts, bindings, and the classics. Our only rivals are the British Museum and the Bibliothèque Nationale. I hope to be able to say some day that there is neither rival nor equal.”  

The Morgan Leaf

The last and finest single leaf from a medieval manuscript that Morgan Sr. acquired was in 1912, a year before his death. Now known as The Morgan Leaf, the recto and verso (front and back) have full-page illustrations know as miniatures. The leaf was originally part of the Winchester Bible, the largest and greatest English Romanesque Bible that is permanently housed at Winchester Cathedral. It was begun around 1160 but the illustrations were never completed. Only two drawings were finished for this project—the ones owned by the library. This double-sided leaf was probably removed from the Bible when it was rebound in 1820, and its artworks are considered a highlight of 12th-century English painting.

Scenes from the life of Samuel are depicted on the recto leaf. The three-register miniatures are in a color scheme of greens and oranges. Their artists’ identities are unknown, so they are called by sobriquets: The underdrawings are by the Apocrypha Master and the illuminations are by the Master of The Morgan Leaf, who was especially skilled in rendering faces with sensitivity. The verso shows scenes from the life of David.

Single leaf from the Winchester Bible, in Latin Winchester, England, circa 1160–1180. (Courtesy of<br/>The Morgan Library & Museum)
Single leaf from the Winchester Bible, in Latin Winchester, England, circa 1160–1180. Courtesy of
The Morgan Library & Museum

Soon after Morgan Sr.’s death came World War I. Both of these events led to uncertainty about the fate of the library. Eventually, Morgan Jr. decided to continue adding to the holdings and to retain Greene as librarian. However, he decreed that collecting would cease during the hostilities.

But on Nov. 21, 1916, even as war continued, Greene visited England and purchased the “Crusader Bible,” one of the world’s greatest 13th-century manuscripts. Six years prior, Morgan Sr. had been offered the Bible and demurred due to its excessive price. The second time around, Greene didn’t want to lose out. After completing the purchase, she informed Morgan Jr., who keenly approved it, as he recognized the historical value of one of the greatest sets of biblical miniatures ever created.

French Gothic Illumination

Saul killing King Nahash and destroying the Ammonites, MS M.638, fol. 23v, from the "Crusader Bible," circa 1244 to 1254. (Courtesy of The Morgan Library & Museum)
Saul killing King Nahash and destroying the Ammonites, MS M.638, fol. 23v, from the "Crusader Bible," circa 1244 to 1254. Courtesy of The Morgan Library & Museum

The “Crusader Bible” dates to Paris, circa 1244 to 1254, and is representative of the zenith of French Gothic illumination. Its provenance is illustrious and global. It has long been linked with the patronage of King Louis IX of France due to circumstantial evidence such as the work’s high artistry, expense, size, and pictorial depictions, including the setting of the scenes in 13th-century France instead of the Holy Land.

After Louis’s death, the Bible traveled to Italy, perhaps with the king’s younger brother. The first documented owner was the Polish Cardinal Bernard Maciejowski, Bishop of Cracow, who perhaps acquired it while visiting Italy. In turn, he presented it as a papal diplomatic gift to the Persian ruler Shah ‘Abbas in 1608 at his capital in Isfahan. The Bible was passed down to the shah’s grandson and great grandson before the city was sacked by Afghans in 1722. Scholars believe that the book ended up with a Persian-speaking Jew. Thereafter, the Bible made its way to Cairo, where it was purchased by a Greek collector from an Arab for a mere three shillings. The Greek sold it in turn at a London auction in 1833 for 255 guineas. The purchasers were local dealers who offered it to the voracious manuscript collector Sir Thomas Phillips. Thereafter, it descended within his family until its sale to Greene.

When this Bible was created, Paris was France’s capital of manuscript illumination. Manuscript production had shifted from monasteries to secular shops, and expansive projects entailed partnerships between shops and artists. The “Crusader Bible” was the creation of seven artists, with a master’s hand visible in almost 40 percent of the miniatures. The Morgan writes that this unknown genius was “a master of naturalistic narrative detail, dynamic battle scenes, and elegant drawing.”

Book of Revelations

A copy of St. Beatus of Liébana's “Commentary on the Apocalypse,” circa 945, by San Salvador de Tábara, Spain. (Courtesy of The Morgan Library & Museum)
A copy of St. Beatus of Liébana's “Commentary on the Apocalypse,” circa 945, by San Salvador de Tábara, Spain. Courtesy of The Morgan Library & Museum

In 1919, The Morgan acquired a Latin 10th-century commentary, aptly called “Commentary on the Apocalypse,” written and illuminated by a Spanish monk. It wasn’t considered a fashionable work when Morgan Jr. purchased it, but Greene wanted it for the collection, having the foresight that an early medieval masterpiece like this would raise the status of the library. The text comes from the 12-book work of an 8th-century monk, Saint Beatus of Liébana, about the Apocalypse, or Book of Revelation, completed around A.D. 776. The Morgan cites its circa A.D. 945 manuscript as the earliest markedly complete copy of Beatus’s original. Its copy was created by the monk Maius, who likely worked at the scriptorium of San Salvador de Tábara; it is among the greatest medieval Spanish illuminations.

Maius was considered an “archipictor,” or master painter. His commentary, which has 110 miniatures, features his own innovations. These are classified by The Morgan as “the prefatory evangelists’ portraits, genealogical tables, and especially the frames and colored backgrounds.” It is in the Mozarabic style, characterized by bright, vibrant colors and expressive, flat figures.

Holkham Hall Manuscript

A detail from the “Gospels of Judith of Flanders,” a manuscript in Latin, 1051–1064. (Courtesy of The Morgan Library & Museum)
A detail from the “Gospels of Judith of Flanders,” a manuscript in Latin, 1051–1064. Courtesy of The Morgan Library & Museum
One of The Morgan’s most charming acquisition stories pertains to the “Gospels of Judith of Flanders” from 1051 to 1064. It was one of four manuscripts that Greene desired to purchase from the collection of the English stately home Holkham Hall, though the price was exorbitant. In 1926, Morgan went in person to complete the transaction with the owner, the third Earl of Leicester. After their meeting, Morgan said wittily: “My librarian told me she wouldn’t dare spend so much of my money, but just the same I wouldn’t be able to face her if I went home without the manuscripts.”

The patroness of the 11th-century book is believed to have been the noblewoman Judith of Flanders. She was the daughter of the Count of Flanders and sister-in-law of the last crowned Anglo-Saxon king. After being widowed, she remarried to the Duke of Bavaria. The manuscript dates to her time in England, but the binding is believed to have been added in the 11th century and is possibly Germanic. The striking bejeweled front cover includes cast figures, enamel, and delicate filigree.

Belle da Costa Greene in the West Room of J. Pierpont Morgan’s Library, circa 1948 to 1950. (Courtesy of The Morgan Library & Museum)
Belle da Costa Greene in the West Room of J. Pierpont Morgan’s Library, circa 1948 to 1950. Courtesy of The Morgan Library & Museum

Belle da Costa Greene was an adviser, librarian, curator, director, scholar, mentor, and a collector in her own right. She was devoted to her work and her bosses. Greene ceaselessly researched and then acquired the best works for The Morgan, savvily negotiating the most favorable deals. Her dedication to medieval illuminated manuscripts shines as brightly in this exhibition as the gold leaf of the miniatures.

The “Belle da Costa Greene: A Librarian’s Legacy” exhibition at The Morgan Library & Museum runs through May 4, 2025. To find out more, visit TheMorgan.org
What arts and culture topics would you like us to cover? Please email ideas or feedback to [email protected]
Michelle Plastrik
Michelle Plastrik
Author
Michelle Plastrik is an art adviser living in New York City. She writes on a range of topics, including art history, the art market, museums, art fairs, and special exhibitions.