Antonello da Messina’s Blue Madonna

Amidst a long lineage of blue Madonnas, “Virgin Annunciate” has a magnetism that compels contemplation.
Antonello da Messina’s Blue Madonna
A detail from “Virgin Annunciate,” circa 1475–1476, by Antonello da Messina. Public Domain
Updated:
0:00
Madonnas dressed in blue have been a foundational feature in Western art since the early 5th century. Historically, the finest blue pigment was exorbitantly expensive, more costly than gold, and its use for Mary the Mother of God was a means of honoring her. Perhaps the greatest painting of Mary that illuminates her connection with this color is the Italian Renaissance artist Antonello da Messina’s “Virgin Annunciate.”
Magnificently painted in oil on wood around 1475 to 1476, the small devotional picture has been compared to the “Mona Lisa” due to its embodiment of magnetic, mysterious, and serene beauty.

The Innovative Sicilian

Antonello da Messina (circa 1430–1479) was a major Quattrocento artist (Italian Renaissance of the 1400s) and the greatest painter of his era to come from Sicily, Italy. Born Antonello di Giovanni d’Antonio in the small city of Messina, he has long been cited scholastically as the importer of the technique of oil painting to Italy. While this is now known to be an untrue assertion, Antonello was technically brilliant—nearly peerless—in the medium. Especially in realistic portraits, he used oil to depict minute details and subtle color. He brought his subjects to life: Sitters appear as if they are partaking in an unspoken dialogue conveyed by their facial expressions.
"Portrait of a Man," circa 1475–1476, by Antonello da Messina. Oil on polar wood; 14 inches by 10 inches. National Gallery, London. (Public Domain)
"Portrait of a Man," circa 1475–1476, by Antonello da Messina. Oil on polar wood; 14 inches by 10 inches. National Gallery, London. Public Domain

The artist’s “Portrait of a Man” at London’s National Gallery is considered a prime example of his lifelike painting. Antonello’s ability to display psychological aspects that offer glimpses of an interior life was innovative in European painting.

Antonello’s artworks reflect cosmopolitan exposure, which was surprising given that his hometown was viewed as a peripheral to Europe. His influences ranged from fellow Italians to Netherlandish artists—oil paint pioneers—along with French, Spanish, and Provençal painters. Antonello spent most of his life in Messina, although there are confirmed visits to Naples and Venice.

It was during his time in Naples, where he may have trained artistically, that scholars believe he was exposed to works by the likes of Jan van Eyck and Rogier van der Weyden. The question of whether he did, in fact, journey to the Netherlands or other countries continues to intrigue art historians, given his glorious distillation of foreign artistic advancements.

One of his most prized paintings is “Saint Jerome in His Study,” remarkable for its harmonious exploration of space and light. Amusingly, a century after it was made, a Venetian art connoisseur declared it must be the work of a Netherlandish artist like van Eyck, dismissing the possibility that it could be from the hand of an Italian.

"Saint Jerome in His Study," circa 1474, by Antonello da Messina. Oil on wood; 18 inches by 14 1/5 inches. National Gallery, London. (Public Domain)
"Saint Jerome in His Study," circa 1474, by Antonello da Messina. Oil on wood; 18 inches by 14 1/5 inches. National Gallery, London. Public Domain
In addition to portraits, Antonello was a great painter of religious scenes and landscapes. A highpoint of Antonello’s career was a 1475 to 1476 sojourn in Venice, to which he may have made additional trips. During this specific trip, he received a commission for the “San Cassiano Altarpiece.” Only the altarpiece’s central fragment of a Virgin and Child surrounded by saints survives at Vienna’s Kunsthistorisches Museum. In its original state, it was, along with other works by Antonello, of great inspiration to Venetian artists such as Giovanni Bellini.
"San Cassiano Altarpiece," 1475, by Antonello da Messina. Oil on poplar panel. Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna. (Public Domain)
"San Cassiano Altarpiece," 1475, by Antonello da Messina. Oil on poplar panel. Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna. Public Domain
“Virgin Annunciate” dates either to his Venetian period or just after his return to Messina. The work is housed in the Galleria Regionale della Sicilia, which is in Palermo’s Palazzo Abatellis. This painting has been subject to misattributions—thought at one point to be by Albrecht Dürer as well as confused with a minor copy in Venice’s Gallerie dell’Accademia. Now regarded as a masterpiece by Antonello, it is considered one of the finest panel paintings of the Early Italian Renaissance.  

Luxury and Labors of Lapis Lazuli

Blue pigment has been revered for millennia. It is difficult to find and extract from natural sources, so it became a luxury commodity with connotations of wealth, royalty, and divinity. Ultramarine is a “true blue” pigment derived from the metamorphic rock lapis lazuli. Famous historic deposits are in Afghanistan. Highly labor-intensive to extract the blue from the stone and prepare as a pigment, the resulting substance traveled throughout Asia via the Silk Road.

“Icon With the Virgin and Child, Saints, Angels, and the Hand of God,” 6th century, by an early Byzantine artist. Encaustic on panel. The Holy Monastery of Saint Catherine, Sinai, Egypt.  (Public Domain)
“Icon With the Virgin and Child, Saints, Angels, and the Hand of God,” 6th century, by an early Byzantine artist. Encaustic on panel. The Holy Monastery of Saint Catherine, Sinai, Egypt.  Public Domain

Today, blue is stereotypically associated  with boys and pink with girls. In the Middle Ages, however, the colors had opposite gender connotations. This can be seen in art: Jesus is often depicted in red (a color connected to pink) and Mary wears blue. Byzantine artists were the first to clothe Mary in a blue mantle, though the cheaper pigment from the mineral azurite was used for these icons. Over time, blue took on symbolic meanings of purity, humility, and holiness.

A composite image with (L) "The Annunciation," circa 1434–1436, by Jan van Eyck. Oil on panel, transferred onto canvas. National Gallery of Art, Washington. (R) “Nostre Dame de Grasse,” 1460-1500, by unknown artist. Polychromed sculpture in limestone. Musée des Augustins, Toulouse, France. (<a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Vierge_%C3%A0_l%27enfant_(RA_788).jpg" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">Daniel Martin</a>/<a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/deed.en" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">CC BY-SA 3.0</a>)
A composite image with (L) "The Annunciation," circa 1434–1436, by Jan van Eyck. Oil on panel, transferred onto canvas. National Gallery of Art, Washington. (R) “Nostre Dame de Grasse,” 1460-1500, by unknown artist. Polychromed sculpture in limestone. Musée des Augustins, Toulouse, France. (Daniel Martin/CC BY-SA 3.0)
Static medieval icons of the Madonna in blue with the Christ Child evolved in the Renaissance to paintings featuring narrative scenes of her life. A breathtaking Mary in blue that predates Antonello’s version is in van Eyck’s “The Annunciation.” In addition, polychrome sculptures from the period show the Virgin in blue.

‘Virgin Annunciate’

“Virgin Annunciate,” circa 1475–1476, by Antonello da Messina. Oil on panel; 17 3/4 inches by 13 1/2 inches. Galleria Regionale della Sicilia, Palermo, Italy. (Public Domain)
“Virgin Annunciate,” circa 1475–1476, by Antonello da Messina. Oil on panel; 17 3/4 inches by 13 1/2 inches. Galleria Regionale della Sicilia, Palermo, Italy. Public Domain

Antonello’s poignant Virgin is draped in a warmly saturated, voluminous blue fabric. She is a young teenager, perhaps 13 or 14, but poised beyond her years. The Madonna sits in front of a dark and isolated background that communicates a sense of sacredness. The artist’s construction of the composition renders her both realistic and enigmatic. She seems tangible: Her expertly foreshortened hand extends over the open prayer book to the viewer in blessing, but her modest pose and lowered eyes convey a reserve.

This version of the Annunciation, which was a popular theme in Renaissance painting, is unusual in that the archangel Gabriel is not pictured. Instead, the artist has positioned the viewer in his place, deepening the emotional connection between the figures within and outside the picture plane. Amid a long lineage of blue Madonnas, “Virgin Annunciate” maintains a magnetism that compels contemplation.

What arts and culture topics would you like us to cover? Please email ideas or feedback to [email protected]
Michelle Plastrik
Michelle Plastrik
Author
Michelle Plastrik is an art adviser living in New York City. She writes on a range of topics, including art history, the art market, museums, art fairs, and special exhibitions.