Book Review: 2020’s ‘The Splendid and the Vile: A Saga of Churchill, Family, and Defiance During the Blitz’

Book Review: 2020’s ‘The Splendid and the Vile: A Saga of Churchill, Family, and Defiance During the Blitz’
British Prime Minister Winston Churchill observes British soldiers operating an anti-aircraft gun during the Blitz, London, England. Hulton Archive/Getty Images
Anita L. Sherman
Updated:

Dec. 7, 1941, marks the date when Japan bombed Pearl Harbor, ushering the United States into World War II.

As much as this date is cemented in the World War II history of the United States and, hopefully, in the minds and hearts of most Americans, bestselling author Erik Larson takes readers on a compelling inside look at the political drama focused on a critical period in Great Britain’s history leading up to America’s entry into the conflict, in his “The Splendid and the Vile: A Saga of Churchill, Family, and Defiance During the Blitz.”

Britain had declared war on Germany in September 1939 in response to Hitler’s invasion of Poland. It was a fearful time for people, knowing that bombing and invasion were now serious retaliatory threats. By the following year, in May 1940, Poland and Czechoslovakia had fallen.

British soldiers with rescue dogs search for victims in a ruined building after an air raid on London during the Blitz in 1941. (AFP via Getty Images)
British soldiers with rescue dogs search for victims in a ruined building after an air raid on London during the Blitz in 1941. AFP via Getty Images
During that same month, 65-year-old Winston S. Churchill, the first lord of the Admiralty, was elected prime minister. He took the reins at a grave time, when Hitler was on the move in Europe. His appointment had not been without internal conflict, and his personal life was complicated as well.

He Takes the Reins

He rose to the challenge in masterful fashion, seemingly undaunted by the mounting pressures that faced him daily on either the foreign or family front.

It’s the unfolding of each day that Larson brings vividly to life. Even though we know historically the ultimate outcome, his narrative (much inspired by private diaries and journals of those surrounding Churchill, some recently available to the public) keeps readers turning the pages. Interestingly, the UK had a vast social research project called Mass-Observation, which was a network of local diarists.

The read is hefty, more than 500 pages—heavier still if you are holding the hardback edition (as I did)—but, trust me, it adds to the ambiance. It brings the weightiness of the situation ever more present.

The fates of nations were at stake, but what is so strikingly revealed in Larson’s narrative is the fact that those pressing decisions were in large part determined by the leadership of two men: Winston Churchill and then president Franklin D. Roosevelt.

The interplay, communiqués, and conversations between Churchill and Roosevelt were, of course, politically and personally motivated and the outcome pivotal to the destinies of so many lives.

Churchill desperately needed more than the spiritual and moral support of the United States. He needed destroyers, arms, and food supplies. Roosevelt, faced with his own challenges and a country unwilling to go to war, was seeking a third term in office. Early on, at one point, he basically said “best of luck.”

Many of the voices we hear throughout come from Churchill’s “secret circle.” We hear the voices of those closest to him as they witness the evacuation at Dunkirk, the fall of France, the losses in the Middle East, and most tragically, the eventual loss of 45,000 Britons to relentless bombing—the Blitz—during the 12 months that followed his election.

Country and Family

The people adored him. He had their heart. Even in the most dire and tragic circumstances, his personal charisma and eloquence lifted spirits and infused his subjects with renewed vigor and perseverance even as they buried their dead. Many of his speeches continue to be shared and reread, his oratory skills legendary.
British Prime Minister Winston Churchill attends the christening of his grandson Jeremy Soames at Westerham Parish Church in Kent in 1952. (Front, L–R) Clementine Churchill holding the hand of Emma Soames, Christopher Soames, Mary Soames (holding the baby), Winston Churchill, and the baby's godfather Field Marshal Montgomery, holding the hand of Nicholas Soames. (FPG/Archive Photos/Getty Images)
British Prime Minister Winston Churchill attends the christening of his grandson Jeremy Soames at Westerham Parish Church in Kent in 1952. (Front, L–R) Clementine Churchill holding the hand of Emma Soames, Christopher Soames, Mary Soames (holding the baby), Winston Churchill, and the baby's godfather Field Marshal Montgomery, holding the hand of Nicholas Soames. FPG/Archive Photos/Getty Images

Churchill was a family man. He had grown children, the youngest being Mary, all going through their own challenges. Larson brings all of the passionate dynamics of Churchill’s personal life to the foreground, balancing this to the ever-present demands on the foreign front.

It’s an engrossing narrative with no lack of suspense, tension, and often delicious detail. Churchill was a curious fellow; his penchant for odd behavior was in sharp contrast to his keen strategic mind.

I particularly enjoyed learning more about Clementine, Churchill’s wife, who while orchestrating their social life at country getaways, remained a steadfast companion and counselor. And, to her credit, she did much to sway Churchill’s decision to improve the conditions of the many shelters necessitated by Hitler’s Luftwaffe.

Larson talks about the intense psychological effects of continued blackouts; the lack of electricity, water, and transportation; food shortages; the layers of broken glass, the destruction of cherished buildings, and the ongoing devastation.

He is deft at describing—and made all the more tragic and touching—the fates of individuals: the singer at a night club, the death of children on an outbound ship, the spouse of one, the friend of another.

While London was at the core of bombing raids, the destruction of smaller cities and towns struck acute terror into Britain’s citizenry. The full moon, in all its splendid glory, gave way to vile consequences as it lit the way for the German onslaught.

Churchill’s sheer will, courage, perseverance, guts, and grace bound a country and a family together in the darkest of times.

Whether you are a Larson fan (“The Devil in the White City,” “In the Garden of Beasts,” “Dead Wake,” “Thunderstruck”) or discovering the master of this genre for the first time, “The Splendid and the Vile” is an informational, insightful, inspiring, and enthralling read: Larson at his best and most brilliant.

‘The Splendid and the Vile: A Saga of Churchill, Family, and Defiance During the Blitz’ By Erik Larson Crown Publishers, Feb. 25, 2020 Hardcover: 608 pages
Anita L. Sherman
Anita L. Sherman
Author
Anita L. Sherman is an award-winning journalist who has more than 20 years of experience as a writer and editor for local papers and regional publications in Virginia. She now works as a freelance writer and is working on her first novel. She is the mother of three grown children and grandmother to four, and she resides in Warrenton, Va. She can be reached at [email protected]
Related Topics