In 2009, a controversy arose during then-President Ma Ying-jeou’s administration (2008–2016) concerning his Taiwan birthplace. Due to his supposed first visit to communist China last week, questions about this story are returning. How will this story play out during his visit?
Why Bring This Topic Up Now?
The Chinese city of Shenzhen had a curious announcement on March 21. The Shenzhen Daily said the following in English on its website:“Spokesperson extends welcome to Ma Ying-jeou.
“A mainland spokesperson yesterday extended a welcome to former Taiwan leader Ma Ying-jeou, who will visit the mainland March 27.
“Ma Xiaoguang, a spokesperson for the Taiwan Affairs Office of the State Council, said the mainland is willing to do its part to facilitate Ma Ying-jeou’s visit, and wished him a good journey.
“Ma Ying-jeou will visit the mainland to pay respects to his ancestors ahead of the Qingming Festival, or Tomb-sweeping Day.
“In the meantime, he will lead a group of Taiwan students who will come to the mainland for communication and exchanges.
“Paying respects to ancestors around the Qingming Festival is a tradition shared by people on both sides of the Taiwan Strait, said Ma Xiaoguang. He added that by enhancing communication, young people on both sides of the Taiwan Strait can create new impetus for the peaceful development of cross-Strait relations.
“'Ma Ying-jeou will visit Nanjing, Wuhan and Changsha, as well as other cities, said Hsiao Hsu-tsen, director of the Ma Ying-jeou Foundation, at a press conference in Taipei yesterday.’”
Why would the Shenzhen Daily post a welcome message in English before Ma’s visit to China? Is there a special relationship between Ma and Shenzhen? Let us look at the historical background.
1 Birth Certificate: 2 Discrepancies
On Nov. 24, 1980, Ma’s first daughter was born in Massachusetts while he was studying law.When someone is born in the United States, the state requires the parents to provide their names, occupations, ages, where they were born, and other information, and to testify that the information is correct by signing the birth certificate. In this example, Ma signed the birth certificate and testified that he was born in Shenzhen.
Additional Evidence That Ma Was Born in Shenzhen
According to press reporting in 2009, at least three different documents showed that Ma had claimed his birthplace was Shenzhen, Guangdong Province, not Hong Kong under UK rule. DPP Legislator Chai Trong-rong argued that Ma had lied about his birthplace.“Showing copies of the three manuscripts at a press conference yesterday, Chai told reporters that Ma’s signatures on the three documents were identical, hence the documents were authentic,” the report said.
Shenzhen is next to Hong Kong, but by 1949, communist China controlled Shenzhen.
Ma’s Official Record
According to the official Republic of China (ROC, Taiwan’s official name) Presidential website, Ma’s family was “originally from Hengshan County in Hunan Province on the Chinese mainland, and born in Hong Kong”—Yau Ma Tei, British Hong Kong on July 13, 1950. According to his former office’s website, his family escaped Hengshan County in Hunan Province to Hong Kong, where he was born. A year later, his family moved to Taiwan.What Other Information Is Available?
Ma’s presidential spokesperson Wang Yu-chi traveled to Hong Kong and claimed that he was able to find Ma’s Hong Kong birth certificate showing that Ma was born in Hong Kong.Ma’s Recent Trip to China
If Ma goes to Shenzhen to visit his relatives, this action will reinforce the previously held argument that it is Ma’s birthplace. If nothing happens in Shenzhen, then the official story could hold true. The question remains as to why Ma wrote Shenzhen as his birthplace on at least three documents prior to his presidency.KMT Party Fears Ma’s Trip Will Help the Opposition
Several Koumintant (KMT) leaders have stated that Ma’s visit to China could have a negative effect on national elections in January 2024 by reminding voters that the KMT wants “reunification” sooner rather than later. In contrast, the majority of the population does not want any sort of Chinese annexation, even a Hong Kong “light version.” The messaging coming from Ma during his visit, as well as how the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) describes his visit, may be key to the 2024 election.Other KMT Mistakes
The KMT downplays Ma’s historical record of decreasing Taiwan’s national security in several areas during his eight years in office, such as removing mandatory conscription to an all-volunteer military force in 2014, reducing service time from one year to four months by 2016, and destabilizing Taiwan’s defense budget.Ma’s Massive Intelligence Failure
Ma’s opening of Taiwan to communist China brought about the “dark decade” due to the massive CCP espionage against Taiwan—the worst national security crisis since the establishment of the ROC. Peter Mattis, an intelligence expert, explained:“From 2006 to the present [2016], more than 40 Taiwanese citizens were prosecuted for espionage and espionage-related crimes involving China, including serving and retired officials, military officers, and businesspeople. ... No part of the Taiwan government has been exempt, including the Office of the President, the National Security Bureau, the Ministry of Justice, and the military. ... The cost was not just to Taiwan’s national security, but to its reputation for integrity and probably the willingness of foreign partners to collaborate in addressing shared intelligence and counterintelligence concerns related to China.”
Divide and Conquer
While in China, Ma parroted the CCP anti-Japanese propaganda by highlighting the trauma that Imperial Japan caused during World War II when he visited the Nanjing memorial. Taiwanese people, companies, and government all have friendly relations with Japan.Reversing the Trend
The current DPP government is successfully reversing the damage done by the KMT to Taiwan’s national security. Over the past several years, the DPP has consistently increased the national defense budget from a low of $9.663 billion in 2016 to $12.958 billion by 2021.Conclusion
When former President Ma returns to Taiwan, will anyone ask him how he helped the island nation maintain its democracy and freedoms (as clearly delineated in the ROC Constitution) and enhance Taiwan’s security?The answer is he will not have done any of these things, and he has consistently degraded Taiwan’s democracy, freedom, and national security.