Before Eric Adams was elected mayor of New York City in 2021, his campaign posted on Twitter, now known as X: “We should protect our immigrants. Period. Yes, New York City will remain a sanctuary city under an Adams administration.”
Less than two years later, now-Mayor Adams is suggesting that the influx of illegal immigrants will “destroy New York City.”
“Let me tell you something, New Yorkers. Never in my life have I had a problem that I did not see an ending to. I don’t see an ending to this. ... This issue will destroy New York City,” Mr. Adams said on Sep. 6 during a town hall meeting on the Upper West Side. “We’re getting 10,000 migrants a month.”
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott, a Republican, began busing illegal immigrants to several large U.S. cities, known as “sanctuary cities,” in April 2022 to alleviate the burden on border cities in his state. And although only a fraction of the illegal immigrants arriving in New York City are arriving on Mr. Abbott’s buses, Mr. Adams has called the program “morally bankrupt.”
A jurisdiction is dubbed a sanctuary because it has enacted policies that shield illegal immigrants, including criminals, from federal immigration authorities and deportation.
The cities Mr. Abbott chose as his busing program recipients are among the 10 “largest sanctuary cities in the United States,” according to the Federation for American Immigration Reform.
As of Sept. 8, Mr. Abbott’s office reported it had bused more than 11,300 illegal immigrants to Washington since April 2022; more than 13,500 to New York City and more than 7,000 to Chicago since August 2022; and more than 2,600 to Philadelphia since November 2022.
This year, Texas started busing illegal immigrants to Denver and Los Angeles. Denver has received about 1,100, and Los Angeles around 480.
Border Patrol agents have apprehended 1,973,092 illegal immigrants along the southwest border in the past 11 months, according to Customs and Border Protection data.
More than 1 million of those crossed into Texas.
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott (C) is flanked by law enforcement personnel as he issues an executive order to designate Mexican cartels as terrorist organizations, in Midland, Texas, on Sept. 21, 2022. Texas Governor's Office
In response to the border surge in 2021, Mr. Abbott started his Operation Lone Star border security initiative in March of that year. The governor deployed troops from the Texas National Guard and the Texas Department of Public Safety to the southern border, increased funding for border security, designated Mexican drug cartels as foreign terrorist organizations, and started his busing program the following year.
“The crisis at our southern border continues to escalate because of Biden administration policies that refuse to secure the border and invite illegal immigration,” Mr. Abbott said in a press release at the time.
“Texas supports legal immigration but will not be an accomplice to the open border policies that cause, rather than prevent, a humanitarian crisis in our state and endanger the lives of Texans.”
Cities Cry Foul
On Aug. 9, Mr. Adams said the influx of illegal immigrants to New York City has led to an “unprecedented state of emergency.” The city cited the lack of work authorization as one of the problems with “asylum seekers.”
“They do not have the authorization to work, so we have to provide shelter. We have supplied food and access to health care. We have enrolled children in schools. We have opened almost 200 emergency sites, including more than a dozen large-scale humanitarian relief centers. And we have assisted migrants with asylum applications,” Mr. Adams said.
“But we are past our breaking point. ... For each family seeking asylum through the city’s care, we spend an average of $383 per night to provide shelter, food, medical care, and social services. With more than 57,300 individuals currently in our care, on an average night, it amounts to $9.8 million a day, almost $300 million a month, and nearly $3.6 billion a year,” he said.
On May 9, the state’s Democratic governor, Kathy Hochul, declared a state of emergency over the influx.
Illegal immigrants use a rope ladder to climb over the wall separating the United States from Mexico in El Centro, Calif., on Oct. 6, 2022. Allison Dinner/AFP via Getty Images
In reaction to Mr. Abbott’s sending 42 illegal immigrants to Los Angeles on June 14, the Los Angeles City Council on Aug. 30 unanimously approved two motions to file against Mr. Abbott and Texas.
The first motion states, “Investigate and report on whether human trafficking, kidnapping, or any other crime was committed on or before June 14, 2023, when Governor Greg Abbott of Texas sent 42 migrants from McAllen, Texas, to Los Angeles, California.”
The second states, “Investigate and begin proceedings on any potential civil legal action that could be taken against the State of Texas, Governor Greg Abbott, or any other entity relating to planning and actions of June 14, 2023. ”
Before the vote, Los Angeles City Council member Hugo Soto-Martínez stated: “These motions are about investigating whether Gov. Greg Abbott committed kidnapping, human trafficking or any other crimes when he sent vulnerable families on a 23-hour bus ride with little or no food or water.
“The competition between these Republicans about who can be the most racist, I think, is just an utter failure and shows, clearly, that they do not have any intention of governing effectively.”
When reached for comment about the motions, the southern border, and illegal immigrants, Josue Marcus, an employee with the Los Angeles city clerk’s office, told The Epoch Times via email that the city clerk’s office “cannot comment on these matters.”
The Los Angeles mayor’s office didn’t respond to The Epoch Times’ request for comment.
Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot speaks during a June 2021 press conference. Cara Ding/The Epoch Times
As with New York and Los Angeles, the City of Chicago calls itself a “welcoming city” to “asylum seekers.”
“We have a responsibility to provide access to shelter, food, and medical care to everyone, regardless of immigration status,” the city website states.
“Many of our new arrivals have walked hundreds of miles, navigating great danger through multiple countries in pursuit of safety and opportunity in the United States. We are committed to assisting each family and individual, providing human services with respect and dignity.”
However, after receiving about 8,000 illegal immigrants via Mr. Abbott’s bus program, then-Mayor Lori Lightfoot, a Democrat, pushed back.
“We simply have no more shelters, spaces, or resources to accommodate an increase of individuals at this level,” Ms. Lightfoot wrote in a letter to Mr. Abbott.
“Though I am sympathetic to the significant challenges that border cities face, this situation is completely untenable. The national immigration problem will not be solved by passing on the responsibility to other cities.”
Mr. Abbott responded to Ms. Lightfoot on May 1, “As the mayor of a self-declared sanctuary city, it is ironic to hear you complain about Chicago’s struggle to deal with a few thousand illegal immigrants, which is a fraction of the record-high numbers we deal with in Texas on a regular basis.”
“You are right that ’this situation is completely untenable,' but this is not a Texas problem—this is a problem for the entire United States of America. ... Until Biden secures the border to stop the inflow of mass migration, Texas will continue this necessary program,” he wrote.
Ms. Lightfoot issued a Declaration of Emergency on May 9.
Neither Chicago’s City Council nor the mayor’s office responded to The Epoch Times’ request for comment.
Dozens of recently arrived illegal immigrants camp outside of New York's Roosevelt Hotel, which has been made into a reception center, as they try to secure temporary housing in New York City on Aug. 1, 2023. Spencer Platt/Getty Images
On Aug. 28, Chicago’s new mayor, Brandon Johnson, and Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker, a Democrat, wrote a letter to Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas stating that the city had spent more than $250 million supporting asylum seekers and requested that DHS streamline work authorization for “non-citizens.”
As with other sanctuary cities, the arrival of buses from Texas to Washington met with resistance.
A representative from Washington Mayor Muriel Bowser’s office wrote to the Secretary of Defense on July 19, 2022, requesting the assistance of the National Guard to “help prevent a prolonged humanitarian crisis” in the nation’s capital.
“The pace of arriving buses and the volume of arrivals have reached tipping points. Our collective response and service efforts have now become overwhelmed: the regional welcome center we helped establish in Montgomery County, Maryland, is at capacity; our homeless services system is already under great strain,” the mayor’s office wrote, according to an NBC reporter, who posted the letter on X.
“With pledges from Texas and Arizona to continue these abhorrent operations indefinitely, the situation is dire, and we consider this a humanitarian crisis—one that could overwhelm our social support network without immediate and sustained federal intervention.”
The Department of Defense declined to provide support. It also declined when Ms. Bowser again requested help on July 22 and Aug. 11, 2022.
Migrants prepare to be transported by bus to processing facilities in Yuma, Ariz., on May 18, 2023. (John Fredricks/The Epoch Times
On Sep. 8, 2022, Ms. Bowser declared a “public emergency,” stating in a press release, “The District’s homeless services system is not set up to support the unique needs of migrants, and our community-based homeless service providers are not staffed to support the needs of migrants.”
She said the emergency declaration allowed her to establish an “Office of Migrant Services,” which, among other responsibilities, would “meet all buses and facilitate onward travel.”
On Sep. 15, 2022, Ms. Bowser repeated her desire to “facilitate onward travel,” saying to Fox 5 D.C., “We’re going to do all that we can in D.C. to make sure that the people have a humane welcome and transfer to their final destination.”
When asked whether the influx of illegal immigrants had given her a “better understanding of what [border states] are dealing with,” Ms. Bowser told Fox 5 D.C. that she was elected to “make sure that D.C. residents have what they need” and that the city’s systems can support its needs.
Ms. Bowser’s office didn’t respond to The Epoch Times’ request for comment.
A bus with illegal immigrants onboard leaves Manston immigration short-term holding facility in Manston, Kent, in the UK, on July 10, 2023. PA
Denver’s mayor, Michael Hancock, issued an emergency declaration on Dec. 15, 2022, in response to a surge of illegal immigrants. However, the influx wasn’t a result of Mr. Abbott’s buses, and Mr. Hancock criticized the Biden administration for forcing cities to spend resources they didn’t have to solve a federal problem.
“Let me be frank: This influx of migrants, the unanticipated nature of their arrival, and our current space and staffing challenges have put an immense strain on city recourses to the level where they’re on the verge of reaching a breaking point at this time,” Mr. Hancock said at a news conference.
“It is at a crisis point right now, and cities all over this country are being forced to deal with something we’re not equipped to deal with,” he said.
Neither Colorado’s Democratic governor, Jared Polis, nor Mr. Hancock responded to The Epoch Times’ request for comment.
A ‘Welcoming City’
Of the six sanctuary cities receiving busloads of illegal immigrants from Mr. Abbott, only Philadelphia hasn’t declared a state of emergency or public emergency.
The city states on its website: “As a proud, welcoming city, Philadelphia will continue to greet our newly arrived neighbors with dignity and respect. City agencies, Office of Emergency Management mass care partners, immigrant leaders, and immigrant-serving nonprofits are working together to welcome, assist, and provide support to these individuals and families.”
President Joe Biden delivers remarks at Prince George's Community College on Sept. 14, 2023 in Largo, Md. Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images
A city spokesperson told The Epoch Times that “Philadelphia has welcomed over 2,500 people seeking asylum and over 60 buses from Texas” since November 2022.
“The city rents a facility as a temporary respite center to welcome people seeking asylum. Immediately upon arrival, individuals and families are greeted by the City’s Office of Immigrant Affairs, the Office of Emergency Management, the Philadelphia Department of Public Health, an array of nonprofit partners, as well as local hospitals providing several essential services,” the spokesperson said.
In November 2022, when the first bus arrived from Texas, Philadelphia’s Democrat mayor, Jim Kenney, criticized Mr. Abbott’s busing policy, calling it “cruel and racist,” but said the city was happy to welcome (at the time) approximately 30 migrants, according to Fox 29. All but two left Philadelphia for other undisclosed locations.
In response to the outrage from cities such as New York and Chicago, the Los Angeles Times recently reported that the Biden administration is considering forcing illegal immigrants to remain in Texas while they await their asylum hearings and wear GPS monitoring devices such as ankle bracelets.
The Epoch Times reached out to Mr. Abbott’s office and Homeland Security but didn’t receive a response by the time of publication.
Katie Spence
Freelance reporter
Katie Spence is a freelance reporter for The Epoch Times who covers energy, climate, and Colorado politics. She has also covered medical industry censorship and government collusion.
Ms. Spence has more than 10 years of experience in media and has worked for outlets including The Motley Fool and The Maverick Observer.
She can be reached at: [email protected]
