Further Thoughts on Our Ministry of Truth

Further Thoughts on Our Ministry of Truth
U.S. Department of Homeland Security emblem is pictured at the National Cybersecurity & Communications Integration Center (NCCIC) in Arlington, Va., on Sept. 24, 2010. Hyungwon Kang/Reuters
Roger Kimball
Updated:
Commentary
The Department of Homeland Security’s new propaganda unit, officially called the “Disinformation Governance Board” but ridiculed everywhere as the Biden administration’s “Ministry of Truth,” has been dismissed as a joke since it was announced last month by Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas.
It is a joke (Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis even wondered if it were a “belated April Fools’ joke”), but it’s minatory as well as laughable.

In this sense, it may serve an important educational role, for few recent developments—apart, perhaps, from the appointment of Joe Biden as president of the United States—illustrate so graphically the critical political lesson that the preposterous oft seamlessly coexists with the malevolent.

Benito Mussolini was preposterous.

So was Adolf Hitler.

But both were also malevolent.

So it is with the Biden administration’s new department of suppression and narrative rehabilitation.

Please don’t purse your lips and remind me about Godwin’s Law.

To point out that Hitler illustrates the proposition that someone can be both ridiculous and malevolent is not to say someone who is both ridiculous and malevolent is, or is like, Hitler.

No, it’s simply to say that both are ridiculous and malevolent.

The fact that the director of this new effort to police speech is an “internationally recognized expert on disinformation” named Nina Jankowicz makes my point.

The ridiculousness is the first thing you notice.

As Exhibit A, I offer this universally mocked video by Jankowicz.

The malevolent part is obvious when you see what it is that she regards as Trump-inspired, Russian-inflected “disinformation.”

Hunter Biden’s laptop, for example.

Even The New York Times now acknowledges that the “laptop from hell” is real, i.e., that its hard drive contains material not only about Hunter’s Satyricon-like sex life and drug abuse, but also Hunter’s business dealings with foreign powers that involve the “Big Guy,” Joe Biden, president of the United States.

The New York Post broke the story just a week or two before the 2020 presidential election.

The entire media suppression apparatus swung into action immediately and suppressed the story.

Twitter gagged anyone who mentioned it.

It’s pretty clear that had the story, which was true, been allowed to circulate, the results of the 2020 would have been different, which is to say Trump’s victory would have had to have been acknowledged.

So you see how Jankowicz’s branding of the story as “Republican” or “Trumpist” or “Russian” disinformation is partly funny but also partly malevolent.

It was one of the events that compromised a U.S. presidential election.

That was the point, of course, but that fact doesn’t make Jankowicz’s false claim any less malevolent.

Here we have a patently partisan activist invested with the responsibility to police speech for the country’s Department of Homeland Security.

Think about that.

Nor is the Hunter Biden wheeze an aberration.

Naked partisanship is the name of this game, which is why this new propaganda bureau has been saddled with a name right out of Orwell’s “Nineteen Eighty-Four,” the Ministry of Truth.

In Orwell’s book, of course, the ironically named institution has two tasks: to suppress the truth and to spread lies.

So it is with the “Disinformation Governance Board.”

The latest lie concerns Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.), one of the members of The Squad.

It has long been alleged, but also ignored, that Omar was for several years married to her brother.

Scott Johnson at Powerline was indefatigable in chasing that story, as was David Steinberg of PJ Media.

The evidence that she married Ahmed Nur Said Elmi appears to be overwhelming, indeed dispositive.

Yet as Alpha News has just reported, Jankowicz has dismissed this fact as a “racist trope.”

“Ilhan Omar is a favorite for this sort of racist, sexual rhetoric that’s compounded,” Jankowicz claimed; “the idea that she married her brother to immigrate to the United States, for instance.”

But it’s not “an idea.”

It’s likely a fact.

Omar was married to Elmi from 2009 to 2017.

She then remarried her first husband, Ahmed Hirsi, just before she began her campaign for Congress.

She is now married to a political consultant named Tim Mynett.

Nice detail: Mynett’s company received nearly $3 million from his wife’s campaign funds.

It’s nice to be part of the nomenklatura.

The Alpha News story drily reports that “Republicans are questioning whether Jankowicz has the proper credentials to lead the disinformation board” and wonder further whether the agency will be used as “a political tool.”

I think that there can be no question about either.

Jankowicz is clearly, indeed ostentatiously unfit to lead any such agency and the agency itself is clearly an unacceptable, not to say un-American, effort to suppress free speech.

Views expressed in this article are opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.
Roger Kimball
Roger Kimball
Author
Roger Kimball is the editor and publisher of The New Criterion and publisher of Encounter Books. His most recent book is “Where Next? Western Civilization at the Crossroads.”
Related Topics