“American and Japanese ‘alliance managers’ have boasted for years that the alliance has never been stronger,” said Grant Newsham, a senior research fellow at the Japan Forum for Strategic Studies. “One fairly asks: Compared to what?”
“Except for their two navies, the U.S. forces and JSDF really cannot work together very well at all,” Newsham added. “This needs to be fixed.”
Japan’s (Self) Defense of Taiwan
Following World War II, Japan’s constitution was amended to allow for national self-defense forces while barring the buildup of an expeditionary military. Over time, Japan’s military policies slowly evolved to incorporate the defense of its allies as an extension of its self-defense.“Militarily, Japan has not yet addressed JSDF shortcomings and developed JSDF capabilities needed to allow JSDF to fight a war against a serious opponent,” Newsham said.
“The Americans and Japanese apparently do not have a joint operational plan in the event something happens with Taiwan.” Newsham added. “There is also no joint Japan-US headquarters in Japan, or anywhere, where operations will be directed, or even peacetime training and exercises.”
Robert Eldridge, director for Northeast Asia at the Global Risk Mitigation Foundation and senior fellow at the Japan Strategic Studies Forum, also believed that the Kishida government would need to commit greater resources to tangibly increasing its defense of Taiwan if it hoped to successfully deter China.
“Japan is not doing enough to end Taiwan’s diplomatic isolation and preserve its safety and security,” Eldridge said in an email. “Speeches and comments are not enough. While they do send a message, it needs to be backed up.”
To that end, Eldridge commended Nakayama’s comments on Taiwan, and hoped that the Kishida government would follow suit with greater diplomatic and military commitment, which he believed the Japanese people would favor.
A Time for Choosing
A key issue at hand with the coming of the Kishida government, then, is how Japan as a democratic nation will build new capabilities from the successes of its involvement with the Quad.“I think Kishida will keep things going on the current trend,” Newsham said. “But that’s the problem.”
“Japan’s defense is entirely inadequate, and without the Americans around the Japanese would be in big trouble. It would have no good options for taking on the Chinese aggressors, and no options at all that don’t involve nuclear weapons.”
Newsham said that at the end of the day Japan was one of the United States’ key allies, and that its dedication to democratic principles ought not be overlooked.
“Sure, we have some differences, but Japan is a splendid example of individual freedom, rule of law, and consensual government,“ Newsham said. ”So is Taiwan for that matter.”
“A solidly linked US-Japan alliance with JSDF and US forces also solidly linked and able to operate together is, or will be, hugely stabilizing for the region and globally.”
Likewise, Eldridge said that Japan’s commitment to democratic principles demanded greater action, adding that the time to choose greater involvement and military responsibility was fast approaching.
“Japan and the LDP-led government as a whole, and Kishida’s faction in particular, are historically committed to the democratic principles of the postwar,” Eldridge said, referring to the ruling Liberal Democratic Party. “I would like to see Kishida do it more forcefully in the case of China, however.”
“[Japan] needs to understand that the world as a whole, the region in particular, and its only formal ally, the United States, expects Japan to play a larger role,” Eldridge said.