Ontario Education Minister Says to Halt ‘Equity-Informed’ Weeding of School Library Books

Ontario Education Minister Says to Halt ‘Equity-Informed’ Weeding of School Library Books
Ontario Education Minister Stephen Lecce stands in the library at Ogden Junior Public School in Toronto, on Nov. 27, 2019. Chris Young/The Canadian Press
Tara MacIsaac
Updated:
0:00
An Ontario school board has been “weeding” out all books published before 2008 with the goal of removing any “harmful, oppressive, or colonial content,” according to the board’s directive to school libraries.

The Peel District School Board (PDSB) directive suggests many books from the past are “inherently racist, classist, heteronormative, and/or sexist.”

The issue gained attention after the CBC published an article about empty PDSB school library shelves on Sept. 13. A group called Libraries Not Landfills has raised awareness of these purging efforts at PDSB, saying “the arbitrary relegation of books to the dumpster for simply being old is abhorrent.”

Ontario Education Minister Stephen Lecce says the board should stop this weeding.

It is “offensive, illogical and counterintuitive” to remove books from years past that educate students on history or are celebrated literary classics, he said in a statement emailed to The Epoch Times. He also noted that some old books, such as “The Diary of Anne Frank,” can teach about antisemitism.

PDSB did not reply to an Epoch Times inquiry as of publication time. The board said in its directive, which is posted on the Libraries Not Landfills website, that its audit and weeding is an effort to comply with the education minister’s directions.
The minister’s directions to this effect are also posted on the group’s website. They say the board should “evaluate books, media, and all other resources currently in use for teaching ... for the purpose of utilizing resources that are inclusive and culturally responsive.”

The book evaluation, the directions say, should be part of a “comprehensive diversity audit of schools, which shall include naming, mascots, libraries, and classrooms.” The directive says the school should submit a final audit report by June 30, 2022.

The PDSB directive to libraries says library staff must let go of their personal biases.

“Holding onto personal biases such as ‘But I love/loved that book’ promotes practices that prioritize teacher-centered approaches, rather than ensuring that students have access to current, compelling, and relevant resources,” it says.

“The category of ‘Classics’ typically consists of Euro-centric texts that were penned long before students’ birth dates, and may not reflect the lived experiences of students within the Peel District School Board,” it continues.

One of the “frequently asked questions” included in the directive is “How was the 15-year weeding date chosen?” This 2008 cut-off date was chosen, it says, “to maintain the currency and relevance of the collection.” It says educators must serve a diverse community and emphasize “anti-racism and anti-oppression.”

Related Topics