Discussions to Return Remaining Members of Bali Nine Underway

Discussions around the return of the remaining five members of the Bali Nine are ongoing, following a meeting at the APEC summit in Peru last week.
Discussions to Return Remaining Members of Bali Nine Underway
Australia's Prime Minister Anthony Albanese is pictured during the group photo after attending the meeting on Sustainable Development and Energy Transition at the G20 Leaders' Meeting in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, on Nov. 19, 2024. Mauro Pimentel/AFP via Getty Images
Updated:
0:00

Following a meeting between Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto, discussions concerning the return of the five remaining Bali Nine members to Australia are underway.

The imprisonment of the five Australians was discussed at the APEC summit in Peru on Nov. 16.

Indonesia’s Law Minister Supratman Andi Agtas told Reuters his government had agreed to return the remaining members of the Bali Nine to Australia. He said it will also seek repatriation of Indonesian prisoners held in Australia.

“This is the president’s discretion, but in principle, the president has agreed on humanitarian grounds,” Supratman said.

He said Jakarta has no set procedures concerning international prison transfer but would work on the matter promptly, noting that the judicial process of Indonesia must be recognised and respected.

“This is important to maintain a good relationship with friendly countries. But this is also in our interest because we have prisoners abroad, he said.”

Who Are the Bali Nine?

In 2005, nine Australians were imprisoned in Bali for attempting to smuggle 8.3 kilograms (18 pounds) of heroin out of Indonesia and into Australia.

The ring leaders of the group, Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran were executed in 2015 and another member, Tan Duc Thanh Nguyen, died of stomach cancer in jail in 2018.

The 2015 executions impacted the diplomatic relationship between the two nations, with Australia recalling its ambassador to Indonesia in protest.

The only woman in the group, Renae Lawrence, had her sentence commuted in 2018, but five of the original group remain in prison serving life sentences.

The five individuals still in the Indonesian prison system are Scott Rush, Matthew Norman, Si-Yi Chen, Martin Stephens, and Michael Czugaj.

Reaction of the Coalition

Shadow Attorney-General Michaelia Cash said it was “almost inexplicable” that Albanese had not explained the decision.

“Let’s be clear in the first instance, these individuals, Australians, were part of a heroin smuggling ring to bring back into Australia in excess of eight kilos of heroin,” she told Sky News Australia.

“Drug offences are some of the worst offences our society sees because of the devastating consequences on people, including death.”

Cash said the prime minister needed to be upfront with Australians about who was paying for the deal and what Australia is giving up in return.

She also stated that the fate of the Bali Nine is a “timely reminder” for Australians traveling to Bali over Christmas, that people arrested in Indonesia are tried under its laws and face tough sentences.

Labor Response

Trade and Tourism Minister Don Farell said Albanese’s role is to represent Australian interests abroad and noted discussions were ongoing.

“The proposal isn’t, as I understand it, to release these people. They would continue to serve their sentence, except they’re serving them in Australia,” he told Sky News.

Farell said that it’s clear the prime minister has advocated for the imprisoned Australians. “We'll see what happens in the days and the weeks ahead,” he said.

Lily Kelly
Lily Kelly
Author
Lily Kelly is an Australian based reporter for The Epoch Times, she covers social issues, renewable energy, the environment and health and science.