Diplomatic tensions between Australia and New Zealand have flared again after New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern criticised Australia’s counter-terrorism measures following the detention of a dual Australian-New Zealand woman and her two children in Turkey.
The woman is allegedly an Islamic State operative.
“We believe Australia has abdicated its responsibilities in relation to this person and I have personally made that point to Prime Minister Morrison,” Ardern said.
“Our international obligations are important to New Zealand,“ she said. ”Where dual citizenship is involved, our view has been that it’s for New Zealand and Australia to resolve the most appropriate response and ensure that we do not strip citizenship and render someone stateless, especially when children are involved.”
“The legislation that was passed through our Parliament automatically cancels the citizenship of a dual citizen where they’ve been engaged in terrorist activities of this nature,” Morrison said. “And that happens automatically. And that has been a known part of Australia’s law for some time.”
“Australia’s interest here is that we do not want to see terrorists who fought with terrorism organisations enjoying privileges of citizenship, which I think they forfeit the second they engage as an enemy of our country. And I think Australians would agree with that,” Morrison said.
However, the situation is made complicated by the woman’s young children who are not covered by Australian citizenship laws due to their parents’ activities.
“For the children involved, a number of the convention’s guiding principles underpin these rights,” Breen said.
In particular, she noted that countries who have signed onto the convention are required to ensure the child is protected against all forms of discrimination or punishment based on the status or activities of the child’s parents.”
“These are rights, not privileges,” Breen said.
Prime Minister Ardern agrees with this sentiment.
“The welfare of the children also needs to be at the forefront in this situation,” Ardern said.
“These children were born in a conflict zone through no fault of their own. Coming to New Zealand, where they have no immediate family, would not be in their best interests. We know that young children thrive best when surrounded by people who love them,” she said.
More than 60 Australian women and children are currently in detention camps in Syria’s north-east since the collapse of the Islamic State in Syria in 2019.