Pro-Palestinian Protesters Threaten to Disrupt Harvard’s Graduation Ceremonies

The threat comes after the university handed out sanctions to more than 35 students that will keep some of them from graduating.
Pro-Palestinian Protesters Threaten to Disrupt Harvard’s Graduation Ceremonies
A Harvard University tour group outside closed gates at the university on April 29, 2024. (Alice Giordano/Epoch Times)
Alice Giordano
5/20/2024
Updated:
5/20/2024
0:00

Pro-Palestinian students have threatened to disrupt graduation ceremonies at Harvard University after the school handed out sanctions including suspensions to at least 35 students.

This included seniors who were slated to graduate from the Ivy League university this week.

The threat was outlined in posts on various social media outlets by the Harvxrd Palestine Solidarity Committee (deliberately spelled with an “x” instead of an “a”) and Harvard Out of Occupied Palestine (HOOP).

The threat to disrupt the graduation over sanctions that were issued on May 17 comes only days after pro-Palestinian protesters ended their three-week encampment at the university.

The group said they decamped after what they say they perceived as a promise by Harvard University President Alan Garber of either leniency or dismissal of charges against the student protesters.

“Harvard has violated its agreement with student protestors,” the groups charged in a statement posted on social media platform X on May 18.

“If Harvard won’t live up to their promises, we see no reason to live up to ours.”

Neither Mr. Garber nor the college’s Public Affairs and Communications office responded to inquiries from The Epoch Times about the newly imposed sanctions or the university’s planned response to the threats.

According to the pro-Palestinian groups, as part of the sanctions, at least a dozen students will be prevented from participating in commencement ceremonies, and at least another 20 will be forced to withdraw from the college.

In response to the sanctions, the groups quickly organized an “emergency rally” outside Harvard’s iconic black iron main gate and posted video footage on their Instagram page.

At the rally, protesters said there would be “disruptions” of the May 23 graduation ceremonies.

“If Harvard wanted a peaceful Commencement, they should not have threatened us and our most vulnerable student organizers,” one of the protesters, who is identified by the group Canary Mission as Harvard Law School student Lea Kayali, said.

The group describes her as an organizer of an anti-Israel Harvard group on campus. Ms. Kayali did not respond to inquiries from The Epoch Times.

She has spoken at other pro-Palestinian events and was recently highlighted as “an inspiring movement lawyer” by The Flaw, which describes itself as a “systemic justice project.”

Other threats to disrupt graduation ceremonies also came from HOOP.

In an Instagram post, it stated, “Commencement will not proceed as normal while Harvard penalizes the students that speak against genocide.”

The group points to a May 14 letter by Mr. Garber in which he wrote that “with the disruption to the education environment caused by the encampment now abated,” he would ask school officials to follow past practices in deciding the disciplinary action of the student protesters.

“I will ask that the Schools promptly initiate applicable reinstatement proceedings for all individuals who have been placed on involuntary leaves of absence,” he said.

“I will also ask disciplinary boards within each School to evaluate expeditiously, according to their existing practices and precedents, the cases of those who participated in the encampment.”

The pro-Palestinian groups contend that Harvard’s precedent has been “dropping charges and refraining from imposing severe consequences.”

“This was the outcome for student organizers in the South Africa Apartheid encampment, Living Wage occupation of Mass Hall, Fossil Fuel divestment blockades, and Belinda Hall occupation,” they stated.

On May 20, several pro-Palestinian student organizations posted letters on social media condemning the punishment against the students as the “Palestine exception to free speech.”

The Harvard-Radcliffe Asian American Association, which had previously pledged support for the protests, noted that at least 11 of the students who face either probation or withdrawal are Asian and accused the college of “unjust silence” of students advocating “Palestinian human rights.”

A sign posted on one of the gates at Harvard University, on April 29, 2024. (Alice Giordano/Epoch Times)
A sign posted on one of the gates at Harvard University, on April 29, 2024. (Alice Giordano/Epoch Times)

Before the student encampments, anti-Semitism had already escalated at Harvard and on other campuses throughout the nation following the Oct. 7, 2023, massacre of Israeli civilians by the Hamas terrorist group.

On Oct. 18, a little more than a week after the attack that left 1,200 Israelis dead and hundreds taken captive, a video went viral on social media showing a group of anti-Israel protesters harassing a Jewish student at Harvard Business School.

The college came under congressional investigation after it was accused of condoning anti-Semitism on campus—a charge that prompted Harvard President Claudine Gay to resign.

Pro-Palestinian student groups have charged that Israel provoked the attacks by occupying what the students have called stolen land from the Palestinians. They accuse Israel of responding with a genocide of innocent Palestinians, a charge the Israeli government denies as its military is trying to wipe out Hamas.

At Harvard and other campuses, students have demanded that their colleges divest any investments in companies tied to Israel.

In a letter Mr. Garber issued a week before the students broke down their encampment, he wrote that the group posed numerous safety concerns and caused enough fear in some students to leave campus.

“We are especially troubled by increasing reports that some within, and some supporting, the encampment have intimidated and harassed other members of our community,” he said.

“When Harvard staff have requested to see IDs in order to enforce our policies, supporters of the encampment have at times yelled at them, tried to encircle them, and otherwise interfered with their work.”

Mr. Garber also said in the May 6 letter that the college had received reports from passersby of being “confronted, surveilled, and followed” by pro-Palestinian student protesters.

The encampments led to the temporary shutdown of Harvard’s daily public tours. For at least a week, tourists could be seen peering through locked gates to catch a glimpse of Harvard Yard.

Alice Giordano is a freelance reporter for The Epoch Times. She is a former news correspondent for The Boston Globe, Associated Press, and the New England bureau of The New York Times.
Related Topics