Michael Ray McLellan, 34, was identified as the suspect in the killing, the FBI and Lumberton Police Department said. He was already in custody on charges in an unrelated case.
He appeared before a state magistrate at the Robeson County Detention Center early on Saturday and is being held in the county’s detention center with no bond.
His first court appearance at the Robeson County Courthouse is slated at 9 a.m. on Dec. 10.
Abduction and Search
Aguilar, 13, was grabbed from her front yard in Lumberton on Nov. 5 by a man dressed in black wearing a yellow bandana and spirited away in a stolen vehicle.The stolen vehicle was found off Quincey Road on Nov. 8.
The community mourned the loss of Aguilar after her body was found.
He funeral was slated for Dec. 8 at 12 p.m. at Lumberton High School, after a Dec. 7 Catholic mass at St. Francis De Sales Catholic Church. She was set to be laid to rest in Meadowbrook Cemetery.
Killer Likely Knew Teen
A profiler said prior to McLellan’s arrest that the person who killed the teenager likely knew her.Michael Teague, a forensic psychologist who previously worked as a criminal profiler for both the Raleigh Police Department and what is now the North Carolina Department of Public Safety, said the circumstances surrounding the abduction indicate the killer and girl knew each other.
Minutes before the abduction, security footage showed a man walking toward the trailer park where Aguilar lived. Teague said clues could be gleaned from the footage even though the man’s face is obscured.
He also said that the autopsy results will help in the investigation.