High-Achieving Family Celebrating Birthday Killed in New York Plane Crash

The family left behind a legacy of achievements in medicine, academics, and athletics.
High-Achieving Family Celebrating Birthday Killed in New York Plane Crash
James Santoro (L) and Karenna Groff in 2023. Courtesy of John Santoro via AP
Rudy Blalock
Updated:
0:00

A private plane crash in upstate New York on April 12 claimed the lives of a family who were traveling to celebrate a birthday and the Passover holiday, leaving behind a legacy of achievements in medicine, academics, and athletics.

The twin-engine Mitsubishi MU-2B went down around noon in a muddy field in Copake about 10 miles south of Columbia County Airport, according to National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) officials.

Among the victims were former MIT soccer player Karenna Groff, who was celebrating her 25th birthday, her parents, her boyfriend, and her brother. Groff, named the 2022 NCAA woman of the year, had co-founded openPPE, an organization that helped create a new mask design for essential health care workers during the COVID-19 pandemic, and was studying at New York University’s medical school.

Groff had said about her NCAA award, “Really, this recognition is a testament to my MIT women’s soccer family and all of the guidance, support, and friendship they have provided for me over the years.”

Groff’s boyfriend, James Santoro,  was an investment banker. His father, John Santoro, said the two will be greatly missed.

“The 25 years we had with James were the best years of our lives, and the joy and love he brought us will be enough to last a lifetime,” John Santoro said.

Groff’s brother, Jared, 26, was a former basketball player at Swarthmore College who scored more than 1,000 points as a point guard at Weston High School. His girlfriend, Alexia Couyutas Duarte, 24, who had recently been accepted to Harvard Law School, was also on board.

“They were all so accomplished, but it was never about their accomplishments,” John Santoro added, referring to both couples. “Everyone considered them such a bright spot in their life. I’m sad for myself and my family, but I’m sad for everyone else who’ve lost them too.”

Couyutas Duarte’s sister, Maria Claudia Couyutas Duarte, said, “That was her dream—to go to Harvard.”

“We’ve never even met anyone who’s ever gone to Harvard. It was so outside of her reach, and yet she made it happen,” she said.

The aircraft was piloted by Dr. Michael Groff, a distinguished neurosurgeon and experienced pilot who had completed additional safety training for the high-performance aircraft in October, NTSB officials said during a media briefing on April 14.

His wife, Dr. Joy Saini, an accomplished pelvic surgeon and founder of Boston Pelvic Health and Wellness, was also on board the flight.

“Michael and Joy were wonderful, warm parents and distinguished physicians who treasured their children,” family friend Jonathan Becker said.

Minutes before the crash, Michael Groff had radioed air traffic control, reporting he had missed the initial approach and requested new coordinates. Controllers attempted to relay low-altitude warnings three times but received no response, according to NTSB official Todd Inman.
(L–R) Dr. Michael Groff, Karenna Groff, Dr. Joy Saini, and James Santoro in 2024. (Courtesy John Santoro via AP)
(L–R) Dr. Michael Groff, Karenna Groff, Dr. Joy Saini, and James Santoro in 2024. Courtesy John Santoro via AP

Weather conditions at the time included a 400-foot ceiling and 93 percent humidity, which NTSB described as “deteriorating” and at the “absolute minimum” for an instrument flight approach landing at that airport.

Inman said during the April 14 media briefing that the NTSB is conducting an investigation and has assembled teams to examine air traffic control records, engine components, and avionics equipment.

They expect a preliminary report on the cause of the crash to be released within 30 days.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.