Judge Issues Arrest Warrant for Homeless Man Accused in GoFundMe ‘Good Samaritan’ Scam

A judge has issued an arrest warrant for a homeless man charged with conspiring to defraud donors in a GoFundMe scam after he failed to show up in court.

Johnny Bobbitt was due to make a Jan. 8 appearance in a New Jersey court to face charges of violating court-ordered conditions that allowed for his release from jail while awaiting trial.

Bobbitt’s lawyer, John Keesler, told The Associated Press he spoke with his client Friday and expected him to appear in court.

Prosecutors say the 35-year-old conspired with Katelyn McClure and her then-boyfriend Mark D’Amico to devise a story about Bobbitt giving McClure his last $20 for gas. McClure and D'Amico then set up the GoFundMe campaign ostensibly to raise money for the homeless vet as an act of gratitude.

“It was an irresistibly heartwarming tale,” said Scott Coffina, the Burlington County Prosecutor, in a November press conference, before alleging that the feel-good story was, in fact, a fraudulent ruse.

“The entire campaign was predicated on a lie,” Coffina said, according to The Associated Press. “It was fictitious and illegal and there are consequences.”

Bobbit and the New Jersey couple raised $400,000, which authorities say was spent on luxury items and casino trips.

GoFundMe representatives said earlier they have returned money to donors who fell for the feel-good story after the donation drive was exposed as a get-rich-quick scam. Bobby Whithorne, a GoFundMe spokesperson, told CBS News on Dec. 24 in an email that all the money, including processing and administration fees, was returned.

Meanwhile, the trio faces criminal charges of conspiracy and theft by deception, in what Coffina said was a get-rich-quick scheme that “hoodwinked an awful lot of people.”

The Heartwarming Tale

The couple claimed Bobbitt helped out the stranded McClure with some gas money.

McClure posted the heartwarming rescue story on social media, directing people to the GoFundMe donation page.

“Let’s do something special,” McClure wrote, as news of the homeless man’s supposedly selfless act quickly went viral.

Johnny Bobbitt (L), Kate McClure (R) and McClure's boyfriend Mark D'Amico pose at a Citgo station in Philadelphia. McClure and D'Amico raised more than $400,000 for Bobbitt, a homeless man, but withheld the funds. On Aug. 30 a New Jersey judge issued an order compelling them to hand over the funds. Elizabeth Robertson/The Philadelphia Inquirer via AP

The funding response was overwhelming. The goal was $10,000, but within nine months the amount collected reached $402,706—an extraordinary result that received broad media coverage.

“It has changed my entire outlook about people, my outlook about people has skyrocketed,” McClure said of the donations at the time.

Over 14,000 people were moved by the touching story to donate money.

The Story Unravels

Burlington County Prosecutor Scott Coffina said on Nov. 15 that that within hours of the GoFundMe campaign launch, McClure had texted a friend saying that the majority of the story was fabricated, according to NBC 10 Philadelphia.

“Ok, so wait. The gas part is completely made up. The guy isn’t,” McClure allegedly texted the friend after the campaign went live, according to the report. “So shush about the made up stuff,” she said, according to Coffina.

The three allegedly met more than a month before the launch of the campaign, authorities believe.

“I had to make something up to make people feel bad,” McClure allegedly said in another text to a friend.

Homeless veteran Johnny Bobbitt, left, and couple Kate McClure and Mark D’Amico are facing criminal charges of conspiracy and theft by deception in connection with an allegedly fraudulent charity campaign. Burlington County Prosecutor's Office

McClure claims she had no knowledge of the scheme.

Speaking through attorney James Gerrow, she stated that she was unaware of the false story and claimed that D'Amico and Bobbit exploited her.

“I’m confident that in the end the evidence will reveal that Kate had only the best intentions,“ Gerrow said. ”She was used by Mr. D’Amico and Mr. Bobbitt and she thought throughout that this money was going to a homeless veteran. She was unaware that they had concocted this scheme. It wasn’t until September when meeting with prosecutors that she came to realize that she had been used by both of them.”

Money Squabbles

The feel-good tale suffered its first visible upset when Bobbitt claimed through lawyers that the couple used the GoFundMe money as a “personal piggy bank,” and sued the couple in August for mismanaging his funds.

Bobbitt’s attorney, Jacqueline Promislo, told The New York Post in September that the couple started to spend the money right after depositing it into their bank account.

“They went on shopping sprees,” Promislo told the paper. “[Bobbitt] tells me they had a Louis Vuitton bag and Chanel sunglasses, a new iPhone 10.”

Then the prosecutor’s office confirmed on Sept. 6 that a criminal investigation had been launched into the missing funds.

Joel Bewley, a public information officer for the Burlington County Prosecutor’s Office, told CBS News in an email that the couple is expected to face a grand jury.

If convicted, McClure, D'Amico, and Bobbitt could face up to a decade in jail.