Florida Democratic gubernatorial candidate Andrew Gillum has cut ties with a campaign aide and vendor who was caught on camera detailing why Gillum can’t deliver on some of his campaign promises.
Gillum’s campaign responded by “severing ties” with Smith.
College Buds
Gillum and Smith went to college together, Smith said. The two “were making a lot of noise” when they attended Florida A&M University, and Gillum was the Student Government Association president in 2001–2002. Both indeed attended the school at the time, according to Alumni.net records.Both remained politically active after college—Gillum as Tallahassee commissioner and later mayor, and Smith as a campaigner.
Gillum announced his gubernatorial bid in March 2017. That month, Smith became the treasurer of a newly minted political action committee (PAC)—A Better Florida for All—which has the stated goal of “building a war chest to prepare for the gubernatorial election that will be held in 2018.”
The PAC spent about $8,000 and was stripped of its registration on Oct. 25 for a failure to pay a small fine.
‘Not for Them to Know’
Smith appeared to possess deep insight into Gillum’s campaign.Gillum has promised Medicare for all, higher teacher salaries, and other spending increases. When asked by CNN who would pay for the Medicare plan, he said he “will absolutely not raise taxes on everyday working Floridians,” but would instead raise Florida’s corporate income tax to 7.75 percent, from 5.5 percent.
“So, Omar, you’re saying that the corporate tax, he’s counting on the corporate tax to fund all the programs he wants to fund?” one PVA reporter asked Smith.
“Correct,” Smith replied.
“What if that doesn’t work out? What else would happen? How would he get the money?” she asked.
“He can’t,” Smith said.
“So none of the programs that people are hoping for would happen?” she asked.
“Basically,” Smith replied.
“Do voters know that?” she asked.
“That’s not for them to know,” he said.
When she asked if they should “keep this a well-kept secret,” he replied: “Yes. Why wouldn’t we?”
A corporate tax of 7.75 percent would be the highest in the region—a likely no-go for the Florida legislature, where Republican majorities in both chambers push for attracting more businesses to the state.
Smith was aware of that, saying Gillum’s promises “will never happen.”
‘Crazy Crazies’
In another conversation, the reporter inquired about what “progressive” means.“Progressive is like the Tea Party of the Democrats,” one unidentified campaign staffer is heard saying in the video.
“It’s the [equivalent of] far right,” Smith explained. “Medicare for all, borderline socialism.”
He went on to say: “Gillum is a progressive. He’s part of the crazy, crazy, crazies.”
“You have to appeal to white guilt,” Smith said, seemingly in reference to how to convince voters to accept Gillum’s agenda.
Before PVA released the video, founder James O’Keefe interviewed Smith, who said his comments were taken out of context, but didn’t elaborate when asked what the context was.
Multiple attempts to reach Smith for a comment went unanswered.
Gillum’s campaign responded to the PVA video by severing ties with Smith.
Campaign Discrepancies
PVA also found similar discrepancies between what candidates say publicly and what they and their campaign staff say privately in North Dakota, Missouri, and Arizona. So far, the videos only featured Democrats.Politicians commonly adjust their message for different audiences, emphasizing the points they think would resonate the most. What the latest PVA series shows, however, is that campaigns would intentionally try to avoid revealing certain policy positions to voters they feel may be alienated by what the candidates actually stand for.