Last week was the worst week for the U.S. stock market since the “COVID crash” of March 2020. Indexes such as the S&P 500 and the Nasdaq are each down by more than 10 percent since April 2. April 4 saw the largest-ever volume of shares traded in one day.
Markets reacted negatively to the new tariff regime announced by the Trump administration, which placed across-the-board tariffs of 10 percent on trading partners around the world, and up to 50 percent additional tariffs on perceived trade abusers such as China and Vietnam.
Under the new framework, tariffs will comprise 20 percent of imports, a level not seen in the United States in a century, and up from as low as 2 percent in recent years. Tariffs are projected to represent more than 2 percent of gross domestic product, a level last seen ... never, at least not in the United States.
Markets Will Correct, Then Stabilize
Equity markets have been overvalued for a long time. The Shiller index of the ratio of price-to-earnings, a measure of relative value for equities, was at the third-highest (most expensive) level ever, only previously surpassed by the dot-com bubble and the global financial crisis, both of which ended in painful corrections. Stocks were priced for perfection, and up to this point investors had ignored the warning signs indicating that they had gotten ahead of themselves. Investors hoped that President Donald Trump was bluffing in making threats about tariffs, and were perhaps caught off guard when they realized he wasn’t.The End of Globalization
We can say with some certainty that the era of globalization and free trade has come to an end. It is being replaced by a system of trade nationalism, represented by higher trade barriers and bilateral agreements, but also one of escalating trade wars and geopolitical competition over scarce resources.What is often forgotten in the debate is that while the United States’ position is shifting, it is only to more fairly align with what our trading partners have been doing for years. China has manipulated its currency, subsidized its industries, and closed its borders to U.S. goods. Japan has kept U.S. products and services out for decades. The European Union has subsidized its industries and limited access (including through mind-numbing red tape) to U.S. goods, and captured excess taxes through the VAT (value-added tax) system. Just because these tools weren’t called tariffs doesn’t mean that they weren’t effective barriers to free trade, placing U.S. companies at a disadvantage.
The US Economy Will Grow Stronger
The U.S. economy is still the largest and most attractive market in the world. The United States is better positioned than any other nation to withstand a disruption to the system of global trade. We have a weakness in our manufacturing base and supply chain, to be sure, but the resources of the nation are now focused on addressing the issue. I wouldn’t bet against Americans on this score.We are more trade independent, have more natural resources, and have more human, technological, and financial capital than our competitors. Therefore, we can outlast them. While China may choose to ratchet up the stakes in a trade war, and we may wince because of it, other countries are already showing signs of capitulation. Alliances will shift, and terms will tilt to the United States’ favor.
The Trump administration is aware of and won’t repeat the mistakes of the 1930s, which featured overly restrictive monetary and fiscal conditions which combined to strangle the economy and deepen the Great Depression.