Offering Alternative ‘Voice’ Models Will Only Prolong Racial Division

The immediate task of Australia, in this post-Voice world, is to learn from the past and get on with the job of making a better future.
Offering Alternative ‘Voice’ Models Will Only Prolong Racial Division
A 'Yes' street mural painted by muralist Tom Civil in Melbourne, Australia, on Oct. 2, 2023. Asanka Ratnayake/Getty Images
Gabriël Moens
Updated:
0:00
Commentary

It would be an exaggeration to describe The Voice referendum as Australia’s nadir moment. But Australia has certainly avoided—at least for now—becoming a country divided by race.

Indeed, if the “Yes” vote had prevailed, a potentially divisive and conflict-ridden organisation would have been permanently enshrined in the Constitution, giving some Australians a privileged position in this country.

In the end, the magnificent campaign run by the “No” camp, especially by the opposition spokesperson for Indigenous affairs, Senator Jacinta Price, and the coherent message communicated to the electorate prevailed.

The message reminded electors that the success of the “Yes” campaign would result in the allocation of special rights to some people and not others.

Indeed, a successful “Yes” vote would not have contributed to reconciliation, but instead would have resulted in incessant demands for more benefits, reparations, land rights, treaties and truth-telling commissions, and more.

It would also have overturned the noble aspirations and achievements of the 1967 referendum, which is credited with promoting a “colour-blind” society.

A No voting card is seen at a vote counting centre in Melbourne, Australia, on Oct. 14, 2023. (Asanka Ratnayake/Getty Images)
A No voting card is seen at a vote counting centre in Melbourne, Australia, on Oct. 14, 2023. Asanka Ratnayake/Getty Images

However, although 60.6 percent of the electorate voted “No,” it is important not to be euphoric because it is a pyrrhic victory.

This is because the relentless pressure for special rights for Indigenous Australians will undoubtedly continue and may even accelerate.

The architects of this disastrous endeavour will continue to push for other benefits.

In this context, our political parties should be blamed for giving in to the politics of victimisation and divisiveness.

Even some factions of the Opposition promised that they might want to conduct a second referendum, involving the establishment of regional voices via Parliament, but would nevertheless add an extra layer of red tape to the government.

Such promises merely continue the debate about the propriety of replacing individual rights with group rights.

So, while the defeat of the “Yes” campaign is obviously very pleasing, it is not something that should be celebrated wildly.

Putting It All Behind Us

It is also most unfortunate that The Voice campaign failed to live up to the requirements of a civilised discussion.

Indeed, the mud-throwing and use of invectives, especially by some proponents of The Voice proposal, have further aggravated the division that the proposal generated in the first place.

Vote Yes and Vote No signage at an early voting centre for the Indigenous voice to parliament referendum in Melbourne, Oct. 2, 2023. (AAP Image/Joel Carrett)
Vote Yes and Vote No signage at an early voting centre for the Indigenous voice to parliament referendum in Melbourne, Oct. 2, 2023. AAP Image/Joel Carrett

The “Voice” debate has revealed just how far along freedom of speech in this country has been eroded.

The immediate task of Australia, in this post-Voice world, is to learn from the past and get on with the job of making a better future for those who now live in Australia and for those who follow, without excoriating those who believe in the implementation of the principle of political equality.

Views expressed in this article are opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.
Gabriël Moens
Gabriël Moens
Author
Gabriël A. Moens AM is an emeritus professor of law at the University of Queensland, and served as pro vice-chancellor and dean at Murdoch University. In 2003, Moens was awarded the Australian Centenary Medal by the prime minister for services to education. He has taught extensively across Australia, Asia, Europe, and the United States.
Related Topics