It’s getting more dangerous to make money and create jobs in California.
Starting in 2026, the threshold would drop to just $50 million of worth, taxed at 1 percent.
And get this. AB 259’s administrative costs alone would start at $300 million a year, then be “adjusted the second year for inflation using the California Consumer Price Index.” Plus another $100 million a year for the next three years, also adjusted for inflation. That comes to $600 million, plus inflation, just to grab the taxes.
AB 259 has been joined by similar proposed new tax laws in at least seven other states, all blue (Democratic) states, of course: Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Minnesota, New York and Washington. The anomaly is Washington, which currently boasts no state income tax.
The idea of the states colluding like this is to prevent tax refugees from taking advantage of the low taxes in other states. Although why anyone would move from California to New York is a mystery. At least California has great weather. The general movement is of tax refugees is to low-tax red states. That can be seen in the recent reshuffling of congressional districts, in which California and New York lost one each, while Florida gained one and Texas, two.
And what if taxpayers flee to other countries and sell all their U.S. assets? How will California be able to tax them? If they don’t pay, will the FTB send the California National Guard to collect?
But with President Biden’s approval rating in trouble, the prospects of Newsom entering the White House have increased. If Lee keeps pushing AB 259 and similar bills every year, eventually a new governor could back it.
According to Lee, “With this modest tax on the ultra-wealthy who pay a lower effective tax rate than the bottom 99 percent, we would have sustained investments in our schools, tackle homelessness, maintain and expand needed services, and much more.”
Actually, the tax, if it becomes law, further would drive the wealthy from California. The U.S. Supreme Court seems unlikely to uphold the part grabbing taxes for 10 years from anywhere on the planet.
And even if that were upheld, AB 259 would be a kind of tax Teflon, repelling any rich people from moving here, or even investing here.
In my 36 years of writing on California taxes and budgets, this is the nuttiest idea yet.