Six years ago, I asked energy companies and others to fund research on why, in addition to being valuable economic commodities, oil and natural gas might be integral to Canada’s and our allies’ security interests. The theory was that Canadians who normally think only superficially about fossil fuels might be more sympathetic to their development if they grasped how dangerous it was for our allies to rely as heavily as they do on imports of natural gas and oil from autocracies and tyrannies.
There was little interest. Energy CEOs seemed convinced that opposition to Canadian oil and gas could be overcome with numbers arguments alone, i.e., by emphasizing how profitable the sector is for Canada in terms of jobs, incomes and tax revenues.
That was a mistake. Too many Canadians then as now believed in either-or choices on oil and gas: Either keep pumping “dirty” energy or give that up and move forward into a bright green future. That was always simplistic, but it made consideration of the economic benefits of fossil fuels seem crude in comparison to the romantic visions of a pure, pre-industrial world offered up by deep greens.
Now, tragically, energy security is a 100-point headline, given Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the folly of Europe’s dependence on Russia for too much of its energy use—dependence that increased steadily over the past two decades as Europeans shut down nuclear and coal electrical generation plants and discouraged new oil and gas exploration on their continent.
There is little reason why Germany or Japan, for example, should continue to rely so heavily on natural gas from not-free countries when liquified natural gas could be extracted from Alberta and Northern British Columbia but also from Atlantic Canada and Quebec, as all have the potential for significant extraction and exports.
Yes, this would require a sea change in attitude among Canadian politicians, but it would be a mature recognition of the actual world we live in, strategic interests included.
In the last century, Canadian families sent their sons to fight and to die in multiple wars to defend Europe and Asia from tyrannies. The least that responsible modern-day Canadians can do is tighten our links with allies. That includes looking at energy as part of a worldwide security pact with other democracies and making it as easy as possible for Canadian energy to get to them.