This reckless alarmism, saturated across the mainstream media and endlessly amplified by it, has had profound societal consequences. It has both distorted public understanding of the massive benefits that the carbon economy makes possible and grossly exaggerated the risks of extreme events that it allegedly makes more likely.
As a result, it has rendered reasonable debate on climate policy impossible, even as it has given cynical politicians an easy scapegoat for every social ill, drawing attention away from regulatory and institutional failures and laying blame instead at the feet of fossil fuel companies and other evil “emitters.”
Climate Anxiety
If there’s any flaw in Mr. Nordhaus’s damning and comprehensive analysis it’s that he undersold just how much damage the advent of “climate anxiety” has done already—and how much more it’s likely to do in years to come.Yes, there are the obvious cases of obnoxious and lawbreaking behavior, from climate iconoclasts defacing priceless works of art to interrupting Broadway shows and sporting events to gluing themselves to buses and holding up traffic on major thoroughfares.
But it runs much deeper than that.
Consider recent headlines. From Vox: “What to do when you’re completely overwhelmed by climate anxiety.” From The Guardian: “Climate anxiety adds to teenagers’ fears.” From The New York Times: “How Climate Change is Changing Therapy.” And perhaps most depressing of all, from the BBC: “Climate anxiety: ‘I don’t want to burden the world with my child.’” The trend is so wide now that they have given it a name: birth strike.
Innovative Solutions or More Activism?
Most of the real action on forestalling or mitigating the negative externalities created by the carbon economy is happening within industry itself. But instead of fueling a new generation of innovators and entrepreneurs to help produce these better, cleaner technologies, climate catastrophism has Gen Z curled up in a collective ball, while the likes of National Public Radio tells its privileged listeners to “Let yourself feel the feelings—all of them” about our coming climate doom.Influencers such as Greta Thunberg are motivating the young to pursue careers in political activism instead of research and innovation. It is easier to make the world angry through protest than to make it better by finding solutions.
Climate fear-mongering has created a dread so powerful that it’s putatively putting people off from having children altogether, at a time when advanced countries are already facing precipitously declining fertility rates.
This bleak picture raises the question of exactly what’s in it for the eco-extremist purveyors of gloom. For Mr. Nordhaus, it’s akin to a religious mission.
Political Opportunism
Mr. Nordhaus doesn’t go far enough. Because it doesn’t really matter whether drastic policy proposals would actually work if the real goal is just acquiring enough political power to dictate them.Anyone who is paying close enough attention knows that these kinds of power plays are cynical, shortsighted, and counterproductive, but what we are collectively starting to realize is how much they’ve been enabled by the literal derangement of generations of well-intentioned folks by climate catastrophism.
All Is Not Lost
As the media reported children weeping in the streets during the highly managed Extinction Rebellion or Just Stop Oil campaigns, shouldn’t there be some other direction for us to take? How can we motivate the next generation to be a force for innovation and positive change rather than feed them a steady diet of nihilism, hate, and anxiety? There are certain things that can be done to frame the future of humanity in a more positive light.Here are some ideas as to how to stop malignant activism from eroding the hopes of humanity:
• Young people need positive mentors who are standing up to the pessimism with positive solutions. Scientists, professors, and influencers need to focus on developing answers rather than acrimony.
• There needs to be better communication on the achievements and success stories of capitalism. The idea that the only solution to these climate challenges is to dismantle industry, restrict global trade, and block free markets is simply ludicrous.
These are a few of the necessary steps to help the public to find a balance between humanity and environmental concerns. On climate issues, there needs to be more hope than horror, more imagination than resignation, and more inspiration than anxiety. With better stories and more responsible storytellers, the climate narrative can be reshaped from one of bitter acrimony to a challenge for innovators to once again push humanity forward.