Chinese Maritime Militia Clashed With US Coast Guard Near Latin America: Report

Taiwan’s security at risk with the expansion of China’s maritime militia

Some of the 220 Chinese vessels are seen moored at Whitsun Reef, South China Sea, on March 7, 2021. The Philippine government expressed concern after spotting more than 200 Chinese fishing vessels it believed were crewed by militias at a reef claimed by both countries in the South China Sea, but it did not immediately lodge a protest. Philippine Coast Guard/National Task Force-West Philippine Sea via AP

News Analysis

An armed U.S. Coast Guard cutter reportedly came into direct conflict with China’s maritime militia off the coast of Ecuador over the summer, according to Coast Guard and non-military officials who spoke to The Associated Press on the condition of anonymity. China’s maritime militia potentially violates international maritime agreements and poses a risk to Taiwan’s security.

The incident took place near Ecuador’s Galapagos Islands in August. When the heavily-armed U.S. Coast Guard cutter James sailed up to a fleet of a few hundred Chinese squid-fishing boats, three Chinese vessels sped away while one aggressively turned 90 degrees toward the James, forcing the American vessel to take evasive action to avoid being rammed.

China’s maritime militia is “a force of vessels ostensibly engaged in commercial fishing but which in fact operate alongside Chinese law enforcement and military to achieve political objectives in disputed waters,” as defined by the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), a Washington-based think tank.

According to the Nov. 1 AP report, U.S. Coast Guard cutter James’s objective was to inspect the Chinese vessels for any signs of illegal, unreported, or unregulated fishing. And it is “perfectly legal” for U.S. maritime law enforcement to board and inspect ships on the high seas as a part of the collective effort to protect the oceans’ threatened fish stocks.

“For the most part, they wanted to avoid us,” Coast Guard Lt. Hunter Stowes, the highest-ranking law enforcement officer on the James, told AP. “But we were able to maneuver effectively so that we were safe the entire time.”

Among the vessels that charged at the U.S. Coast Guard patrol was reportedly outfitted as a refrigerated cargo vessel, which serves as an offshore freezer for transporting fish back to China so that smaller vessels could stay on the water for extended periods.

A Chinese fishing vessel operated illegally in Argentina's exclusive economic zone on May 4, 2020. Illegal fishing by the Chinese regime in distant oceans is plundering global fisheries resources and destroying the traditional livelihoods of many countries. Argentina's Navy Press Office/AFP/Getty Images

A Dangerous Breach of International Maritime Protocol

The Chinese vessels eventually fled the scene after the encounter. China, meanwhile, accused the United States of wrongdoing.

According to the AP report, Beijing released a statement within days of the incident. It raised the issue during an emergency meeting with U.S. Ambassador Nicholas Burns over House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s (D-Calif.) visit to Taiwan, citing U.S. officials as sources.

China’s foreign ministry reportedly told the AP that it has “zero tolerance for illegal fishing” while accusing the United States of flouting international norms by carrying out unauthorized inspections that don’t follow COVID-19 protocols, potentially putting seafarers’ lives at risk.

Although Beijing claimed to have a “zero tolerance” attitude toward illegal fishing, it has repeatedly obstructed international efforts to strengthen inspection procedures in the South Pacific.

According to AP, the most recent stonewalling occurred last year, when China argued that fishermen would be at risk if sea patrol officers were allowed to carry firearms. Meanwhile, rules adopted unanimously in 2011 guided by a 1995 United Nations treaty, known as the Fish Stocks Agreement, allows inspectors to use limited force to stay safe.

The AP said the confrontation on the high seas represented a potentially dangerous breach of international maritime agreements and set a troubling precedent. The report added that “a fleet of 3,000 distant water fishing vessels [is] viewed as an extension of its growing naval prowess and promote[d] with generous state loans and fuel subsidies.”

Fishing boats berthed at a port in Lianyungang, in eastern China's Jiangsu Province, on May 30, 2016. STR/AFP via Getty Images

China’s Maritime Militia

Seafood is key to China’s food security. The country consumes 65 million tons of fish annually, which is 45 percent of the global volume. According to official data, China maintains the largest fishing fleet in the world, with 2,701 boats and ships.

However, Andrew Erickson, a leading American expert on the subject, told CNN that China’s fishing fleet comprises more than 187,000 boats deployed worldwide. Meanwhile, the London-based Overseas Development Institute estimates that over 17,000 Chinese vessels are used in distant-water operations.

According to Radio Free Asia, at least 100 of these vessels and 1,800 sailors operate under the command of the People’s Armed Forces Maritime Militia (PAFMM). This subcomponent of the Chinese armed forces is trained and equipped to support the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) in laying claim to islands, features, and waters in disputed areas.

Fishing boats set sail for the East China Sea from a port in Zhoushan, Zhejiang Province of China, on Aug. 1, 2021. Chen Yongjian/VCG via Getty Images

Carl Schuster, former director of operations at the U.S. Pacific Command’s Joint Intelligence Center, told CNN that the boats have automatic weapons and reinforced hulls and can achieve a top speed of around 18 to 22 knots, which is faster than 90 percent of the world’s fishing boats.

Additionally, the vessels are outfitted with Beidou navigation satellite systems to be independent of the GPS. An investigation by RFA discovered that many boats belong to the state-owned enterprise Sansha City Fisheries Development Co, Ltd., which has managed government projects involving classified national security data.

The boats carry cutting-edge communications systems, transforming them into mobile communications and surveillance platforms that can gather and transmit intelligence back to authorities in remote locations. The PAFMM can be used to track foreign vessels and U.S. aircraft, as well as surveil the shores of countries that are part of China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI, also known as “One Belt, One Road”).

Jay Batongbacal, director of the Institute for Maritime Affairs at the University of the Philippines, claims that the PAFMM plays a significant role in the Chinese Communist Party’s (CCP) plan to establish control over the entire South China Sea.

The 2014/11th issue of Chinese Militia, Beijing’s military publication, stated that China’s maritime militia should undertake logistical support for maritime operations and require relevant units to conduct effective combat training for their fishermen.

Another CCP military publication, National Defense, stated in its 2014/12th issue that militia fishing boats should not only be used in logistics support in wartime but also in maritime patrols, such as gathering intelligence and information in peacetime.

Taiwan’s Security at Risk

On Nov. 9, Chinese leader Xi Jinping called on his military to train for a “new era” and prepare for military conflict over “increased instability and uncertainty.”

Since the CCP has taken over Hong Kong and its militia has occupied chunks of the Indian Ocean and the South China Sea, it is widely speculated that Taiwan is the next target.

The Arleigh Burke-class guided-missile destroyer USS Kidd and U.S. Coast Guard cutter Munro conduct Taiwan Strait transits on Aug. 27, 2021. U.S. Navy/Handout via Reuters

U.S. Under Secretary of Defense for Policy Colin Kahl said an attack on the democratically self-ruled island could come anytime.

“I don’t think in the next couple of years they’re likely to invade Taiwan. But you never know,” Kahl said on Nov. 4. “[Xi] has certainly given his military the charge to have that capability by the end of this decade and probably by 2027.”

In response to the Chinese regime’s growing aggression in the region, the government in Taipei has stepped up security measures, with a strategic shift from purchases of large prestige systems, such as fighter jets and naval vessels, to smaller but just as lethal anti-ship and surface-to-air missiles.

The Taiwan Strait separates the island of Taiwan, which is the only remaining territory from the Republic of China (1911–present), from mainland China, which the Communist Party took over in 1949. U.S. naval vessels have regularly traveled through the strait, which is considered part of international waters.

Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Wang Wenbin emphasized at a regular news briefing in Beijing on June 13 that Taiwan is an inseparable part of China and added: “There is no such thing as international waters in international maritime law. ... Relevant countries claim that the Taiwan Strait is in international waters with the aim to manipulate the Taiwan question and threaten China’s sovereignty.”

A report released by Taiwan’s Ministry of National Defense on Aug. 31 stated that the CCP uses civilian ships, aircraft, and carriers to approach Taiwan and its outlying islands to conduct intelligence collection activities. The report described the CCP’s move as “using civilians as cover for its military” and creating a “gray area” in conflict.

The ministry also said that during the fishing moratorium in the winter, the CCP’s maritime militia would pose as fishing boats cooperating with its navy and coast guards to conduct joint military exercises in the waters surrounding Taiwan.

To counter the CCP’s threat, Taiwan would have to increase its coastal defense forces and patrols during the period, putting strain on the island’s limited military forces.

On Sept. 30, China’s Ministry of National Defense warned that “if the government of Taiwan does not give up its independence, there would be no peace in the Taiwan Strait and that it would not cease its military operations.”