As the Vatican is preparing to cave in to the demands of the Chinese regime in exchange for the resumption of diplomatic relations with China, a world-renowned Chinese dissident has come out to condemn the Vatican’s move as a moral betrayal of faithful Catholics worldwide, in an article titled, “The Vatican Is Making a Deal With the Devil.”
The move is seen as a stunning reversal of the Vatican’s decades-long stance on the issue and has generated widespread criticism of Pope Francis’s leadership. Critics point out that giving up the right to appoint bishops would formally deprive the Vatican of any remaining moral and de facto leadership over Chinese Catholics. It would also, critics say, be a blatant betrayal of China’s underground house church Catholics, who are still heavily persecuted by the Chinese regime.
Among the critics of the deal is Chen Guangcheng, a famous Chinese human rights lawyer who gained international attention in 2012 for escaping house arrest and making his way to the U.S. Embassy in Beijing. Chen has since resided in the United States and has continued his civil rights advocacy and vocal criticism of the Chinese regime.
Chen, who is now a senior fellow at the conservative Witherspoon Institute and a distinguished visiting fellow at the Institute for Policy Research and Catholic Studies at the Catholic University of America, said that the Vatican under Pope Francis is naive to sell-out to the Chinese regime, a deal from which only the Chinese Communist Party would benefit.
“Did the Vatican not understand that in China, everything is subjugated to the will of the Chinese Communist Party?” asked Chen. “Why did the Vatican break relations with China in 1951? It was precisely because the Communist Party insisted that it must control everything, including God.”
The Vatican and the People’s Republic of China have had no diplomatic relations since 1951, as the Chinese Communist Party has insisted from the very beginning of its rule that it should by itself appoint all bishops of the Roman Catholic Church in mainland China so that the regime can maintain control of the church. A regime-controlled Chinese Patriotic Catholic Association (CPCA) was created to supposedly represent Catholics in China.
The Vatican under all previous popes has rejected such an arrangement and refused to recognize bishops unilaterally “appointed” by the CPCA. The power to appoint bishops, known as “investiture,” has been considered to be at the core of the Catholic Church’s teachings.
“Are they pretending to be naive, or are they really that naive?” Chen asked, “Are they really trying to lead the Catholic Church, which has one billion followers, to make a deal with the anti-Christian and antichrist Chinese Communist Party?”
“By making a deal with the devil that is the Chinese Communist Party, the Vatican will only humiliate itself and tarnish the church of God that it supposedly represents,” said Chen.