Geographical Challenges and Safety Concerns Kalish points out the unique topographical challenges of Mill Valley, bordered by a marsh and a mountain, leaving little buildable land. The town’s layout, with steep and small lots, further complicates the addition of a significant number of housing units.
State Mandates vs. Local Businesses The state’s strategy to achieve housing goals involves utilizing underutilized land, often occupied by local businesses. Kalish expresses concern over the potential loss of essential services like doctors’ offices, restaurants, and gas stations, which could transform Mill Valley into a residential-only area, stripping it of its community essence.
The Housing Element’s Flaws Kalish critiques the housing element approved by the state, arguing that it fails to consider the town’s unique characteristics. She fears that the pressure to build will lead to infrastructural and safety issues, particularly in emergency evacuation scenarios.
Traffic, Infrastructure, and Safety Risks The proposed housing plans, according to Kalish, could exacerbate traffic congestion and strain existing infrastructure. She highlights the dangers this poses, especially in emergency situations where evacuation routes are limited.
The Statewide Housing Crisis Kalish extends her analysis beyond Mill Valley, discussing how similar challenges are faced by other built-out cities in California. She emphasizes the statewide issue of unrealistic housing mandates and the lack of consideration for local infrastructural capabilities.
The Threat of Builder’s Remedy One of Kalish’s major concerns is the ‘builder’s remedy,’ which could allow developers to bypass local zoning laws if the housing element is not certified. This poses a threat to the town’s character and planning autonomy.
Rethinking Housing Strategies Kalish suggests a more nuanced approach to housing, focusing on areas with job concentrations and the capability to support additional infrastructure. She advocates for solutions that consider both affordability and feasibility, rather than imposing blanket mandates.
A Call for Reasonable and Realistic Housing Policies Amy Kalish’s insights into Mill Valley’s housing challenges underscore the need for state housing policies that are adaptable to the diverse needs and constraints of California’s towns and cities. Her call is for policies that recognize local realities while striving to meet broader housing goals.
*Views expressed in this video/article are opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of California Insider.
