Nike’s sales dropped across all channels in the most recent quarter, as its “Win Now” turnaround strategy to revive the brand is still a work in progress. Shares of the company traded sharply lower in choppy trading on March 21.
Nike’s weak sales trend dates back to early 2021, when the company prioritized direct-to-consumer distribution over its wholesale model, eliminating intermediaries and the markups that cut into its profit margins.
This change initially boosted the company’s earnings per share and profit margins. However, it eventually stalled the brand’s buzz, as online sales don’t engage consumers as effectively as in-store experiences. Meanwhile, competitors such as Lululemon were expanding their store presence, deepening customer engagement.
Nike’s management saw some progress in its turnaround strategy in the most recent financial results.
“The progress we made against the ‘Win Now’ strategic priorities we committed to 90 days ago reinforces my confidence that we are on the right path,” said Elliott Hill, Nike’s new president and CEO. “What’s encouraging is NIKE made an impact this quarter leading with sport—through athlete storytelling, performance products and big sport moments. ”
“Our outlook for the second half of fiscal 2025, driven by our ‘Win Now’ actions, remains consistent with what we communicated last quarter,” added Matthew Friend, executive vice president and chief financial officer of Nike Inc.
Experts are skeptical about the company’s strategy to turn things around, seeing it as a work in progress.
“A big decline in digital sales and weaker performance across all regions suggest low demand for non-essential items like sportswear,” Georgios Koimisis, an economics and finance associate professor at Manhattan University, told The Epoch Times via email.
“Heavy discounting and rising product costs are cutting profit margins, while consumer interest may shift towards newer and trendier brands. The NikeSKIMS initiative might bring new customers, but the impact may take time,” he said.
“Nike’s issues are not short-term and will not be fixed anytime soon,” Vince Stanzione, CEO of First Information, told The Epoch Times via email.
“They still have much inventory to clear, which means more discounting. Stores are also looking dated, and whilst they have a core loyal customer base, many do not see Nike as a premium brand and prefer smaller, more niche brands for footwear.”
Koimisis sees a connection between Nike’s weak report and those of other companies sensitive to economic fluctuations, such as FedEx.
“Demand for both companies could recover if the economy stabilizes. For instance, if interest rates decrease, inflation increases, or consumer spending decreases,” he said. “A rebound in manufacturing could also help FedEx, especially if businesses start expanding. However, until we see a return of confidence in the economy, FedEx and Nike will likely need to adjust their strategies to deal with the pressure.”
Stanzione sees Nike’s performance as a reflection of the overall market.
“I think recent declines are more of an indication of a cautious consumer and an overall slowdown in consumer spending based on recession fear,” he said.
Patrizia Porrini, a professor of management at Long Island University, believes that a winning strategy isn’t only a matter of upper-level management and developing a culture that supports it.
“Great corporate cultures enable organizations to connect internally and with external constituents such as consumers and shareholders,” she told The Epoch Times.
Stanzione sees no compelling reason to own the stock, which remains at a reasonably high price-to-earnings ratio of 23.
“If I see the stock falling to $50 within the next 12 months, then it may be worth looking at again,” he said.
