Will gold rescue Zimbabwe from the ashes of economic despair and usher in a new economic era?
Since Zimbabwe declared independence from the former Republic of Rhodesia in 1980, the southern African country has been ravaged by inflation and overall economic turmoil. Over the past 40 years, the annual inflation rate has only touched single-digit territory twice: 1980 (7 percent) and 1988 (7 percent).
Excessive money printing, fiscal mismanagement, economic sanctions, and currency instability have been the root causes of its perpetual financial crisis, resulting in political and social upheaval.
In 2019, Harare introduced a new Zimbabwean currency, but it didn’t take long for the revival of hyperinflation, with the inflation rate surpassing 600 percent by March 2020.
After numerous monetary policy trials and errors, the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) experimented with something old and something new: a gold-backed digital currency.
Central bank officials say this money will be supported by 140 kilograms (4,900 ounces) of gold.
The two-phase implementation began with the RBZ selling digital tokens to investors for a minimum price of $10 for individuals and $5,000 for businesses and other entities. The transition will then allow consumers to purchase the digital currency from banks and use the tokens to conduct “person-to-person and person-to-business transactions and settlements” by using “e-gold wallets or e-gold cards” held by these financial institutions. Consumers can also rely on virtual tokens to save their money.
A Lack of Trust
While this policy pursuit might sound like music to the ears of advocates of sound money, a chorus of critics contends that the plan won’t achieve the desired outcome of currency stability.Some economists have expressed doubt about the efficacy of this project, asserting that it isn’t a traditional gold standard because the tokens aren’t convertible to gold bars and coins.
A notable drawback is a paucity of trust in the institutions and officials managing the precious metal, says Aaron Rafferty, CEO of the financial technology firm Standard DAO.
“The critical factor here isn’t gold itself, but rather a reliable, trusted institution to maintain the gold reserves and handle redemption requests,” he told The Epoch Times. “Any nation considering such a policy will need robust systems to manage these requirements.”
Richard Gardner, CEO of financial technology company Modulus, says the better option is to return to the U.S. dollar.
“There is an easy solution here, and it doesn’t involve a digital currency,” he told The Epoch Times. “Instead, the country should simply take its medicine: re-adopt the US dollar. Not only will this move not be the start of an avalanche effect of similar global efforts, it will almost certainly be a failure.”
Currency Experiments
Across the global economy, a growing number of countries are experimenting with digital currencies backed by central banks. Some have already launched these virtual currencies, while others are in the trial phase.Last year, Nigeria released the eNaira, the country’s central bank digital currency (CBDC). However, nearly a year later, the adoption rate has been abysmal, with about 99 percent of digital wallets unused.
The Bahamas and Jamaica also have released digital currencies, while China, Japan, and Russia are testing the digitization efforts of their currencies. Meanwhile, the United States, the UK, and the European Union are still in the research phases of their CBDCs.
Gold: The New Money
Could Zimbabwe be facilitating a new era of gold-backed money?At the very least, the development of a gold-supported digital currency comes at a time when there has been a substantial increase in demand for the metal.
“Our broad expectation for central bank demand in 2023 has, so far, been borne out,” the WGC said in its report this month. “Central bank buying remains robust, with little to indicate that this will change in the short term. As such, we maintain our belief that purchases will continue to outweigh sales as we move into Q2.”
Central banks acquire gold for a variety of reasons, including the diversification of reserves, hedging against inflation and currency risks, and bolstering the credibility and confidence of these institutions. But during geopolitical turmoil and a bloc of nations altering the world order, some officials have signaled that gold could play an integral role, particularly as they reduce their exposure to foreign currencies, like the greenback.
Ahead of the annual BRICS summit in August in South Africa, officials have hinted that the annual meeting will focus on the creation of a new currency that could rival the U.S. dollar or euro, effectively bolstering the global de-dollarization campaign.
While a currency supported by commodities is not universally endorsed, it has been championed by several leading economic figures.
Stephen Moore, a bestselling author and economic adviser to former President Donald Trump’s 2016 campaign, believes monetary policy could be based on general commodity prices, such as cotton, copper, crude oil, and wheat.
She proposed linking the greenback to gold or another commodity instead of just trusting Washington.
“In proposing a new international monetary system linked in some way to gold, America has an opportunity to secure continued prominence in global monetary affairs while also promoting genuine free trade based on a solid monetary foundation,” Shelton wrote. “Gold has historically provided a common denominator for measuring value; widely accepted at all income levels of society, it is universally acknowledged as a monetary surrogate with intrinsic value.”
At a time when the U.S. government is facing astronomical levels of debt—a $32 trillion national debt and trillion-dollar budget deficits—sound money proponents aver that gold could help restore fiscal discipline.
According to former Fed Chair Alan Greenspan, gold limits the amount the government can borrow because it can’t be printed.
However, critics charge that commodity-backed currencies would pose trouble for governments because they would prevent officials from responding to changes in economic conditions and leave currencies vulnerable to commodity price fluctuations. A dramatic shift might also distort the allocation of resources and cause transactional difficulties for everyday purchases.