‘This Is What It Means to Be a Man’: Wisdom From Hunter Donnie Vincent

‘This Is What It Means to Be a Man’: Wisdom From Hunter Donnie Vincent
Donnie Vincent is an explorer, biologist, hunter, conservationist, and filmmaker. SICMANTA
Updated:
What does it mean to be fully alive? For hunter and adventurer Donnie Vincent, it means climbing inside an abandoned grizzly den and discovering the nest of twigs a bear made for the long winter days ahead. Or getting close to a venomous eastern brown snake, learning firsthand of its lightning-fast strike. Or climbing to the peak of a mountain to scour the landscape for elk. It means enveloping himself in the windy, wild, inhuman environments of our world in order to more fully embrace his humanity.

Vincent is based in Wisconsin. He is the founder of SICMANTA, a media production company. (SICMANTA)
Vincent is based in Wisconsin. He is the founder of SICMANTA, a media production company. SICMANTA
Vincent—a rugged-looking man with long graying hair, thick mustache and beard, and clear green eyes that have looked out on many expanses of wilderness—yearns to discover such moments of supreme beauty out in the wild. The Wisconsin-based outdoorsman has made a life of hunting, exploring, and documenting those experiences in writing and on film, such as the widely acclaimed and artistically rendered “Winds of Adak,” produced by Vincent’s company, SICMANTA.

The pursuit of those experiences forces Vincent to undergo extreme hardship and deprivation in the wild. And he wouldn’t have it any other way. “If I’m laying in my tent in the morning and [it] literally feels like it’s gonna blow over, and I can hear the rain, and I know all my gear is already getting wet, and I have to get up and hike to the next location—even at those times, the lunacy of the uncomfortability is comforting to me,” he says. “The suffering, the understanding that I have chores to do, that there’s no one here to save me, that I get these wide open landscapes to myself, is just really inspiring to me.”

Vincent on Adak Island, located on the western tip of Alaska’s Aleutian Islands. With fierce winds that can reach up to 120 miles per hour, it is known as the “birthplace of the wind.” (SICMANTA)
Vincent on Adak Island, located on the western tip of Alaska’s Aleutian Islands. With fierce winds that can reach up to 120 miles per hour, it is known as the “birthplace of the wind.” SICMANTA

Lessons From the Wilderness

Vincent’s thirst for adventure, challenge, beauty, and the outdoors was stirred early in his life, when he was growing up in Connecticut. His father owned hunting gear and would occasionally go hunting, but Vincent’s introduction to a life in the outdoors actually began indoors: through reading. Speaking to American Essence, he recalled the beautiful books about the outdoors in his father’s library, such as the works by Jack O’Connor and Aldo Leopold. The wonderfully illustrated volumes told of adventures in the wild. Vincent knew early on that he wanted to spend his life in the world those books described—and he has.

Among the trophies Vincent collects from around the world, here’s the most intangible one: the new perspective on life he gains from roughing it in the wilderness. When relying on yourself in the wild, he notes, you have to focus on the essentials—food, water, warmth—which lends a deep lucidity and simplicity to one’s thoughts. The basics of survival focus the mind. “There’s something very precious about just worrying about those elements and understanding that all of those elements are your responsibility [to deal with],” Vincent explains.

By contrast, in a world full of modern conveniences and security, where we don’t have to think about the basics of survival, our minds wander to other worries, becoming more distracted, diffracted, and haunted with anxiety. “We worry about many different things that are poisoning our minds and bodies and stealing our resilience,” he says.

Vincent removes a mountain lion—a sheep killer—in the Fraser Valley, British Columbia. (SICMANTA)
Vincent removes a mountain lion—a sheep killer—in the Fraser Valley, British Columbia. SICMANTA
The perspective on life we develop by spending time on a mountainside practicing resilience includes a heavy dose of gratitude and mindfulness, according to Vincent. The hardships he endures in the wild make him all the more grateful for the little joys of civilization: “Because of how I live my life and how I want to live my life, when I get in my truck and I turn the key and it starts, every single time, I think, ‘Whoa, that is so cool that my engine started.’ I’m going to press the gas and get to go to someplace, and my truck is doing the work. I appreciate it every day.”

Recognizing the little things, being grateful for them, and living in the moment—time in the wilderness teaches all these things. Vincent recalls an episode while surveying a valley, searching for caribou, when his eyes alighted on a grizzly bear eating blueberries. He “wasted” his morning simply watching the grizzly eat because he found it so fascinating and wanted to just rest in the joy of the present moment. Such an attitude—though honed, perhaps, in the wilderness—isn’t restricted to remote valleys, windswept arctic plains, or silent northern forests. “It’s a state of mind. It’s not a place that we’re going,” Vincent says. “It’s how we’re living our lives.”

Vincent believes we can all benefit from spending time away from technology and in close contact with nature. “If we could all do that—let’s say it was mandatory in some weird, strange, fictitious world—the mindfulness that you would come home with would serve you tenfold.”

Vincent on a caribou hunt on the Alaska Peninsula in September 2024. (SICMANTA)
Vincent on a caribou hunt on the Alaska Peninsula in September 2024. SICMANTA

He strives to be mindful in his hunting practices by using his skills to help, not harm, wild populations. Hunting is a form of compassionate conservation when it’s used to thin an overpopulated species that risks eating itself out of house and home. Killing a single doe can reduce a deer population by 250 members over the next 10 years. That’s an important step to take when an overcrowded deer habitat makes deer hazardous to themselves and their human neighbors. Vincent has been called in to urban areas on a few occasions to remove does for this reason.

Many hunters, fishermen, and other outdoors enthusiasts keep their finger on the pulse of the natural world. They know what conservation management steps need to be taken and when. This drives a lot of dollars into conservation efforts. As one example, the Pittman–Robertson Wildlife Restoration Act of 1937 instituted an 11 percent tax on firearms and ammunition. The proceeds from this tax go to the management and conservation of wildlife.

image-5789304
image-5789305
L: Vincent catches a Pacific eider. These ducks, which make their home in the Bering Sea, are notoriously difficult to hunt. R: Vincent works on a research project tagging white sturgeon in British Columbia‘s Fraser River. SICMANTA

The Greatest Gift

Far fewer people spend time outdoors today compared to in the past. Even fewer practice the endurance and resilience of Vincent’s lifestyle, and he thinks we’re worse off for it. Resilience, mindfulness, endurance, perspective, and self-reliance “are all things that we have lost as a people, and thus we have weakened ourselves an unbelievable amount,” he says.
Author Michael Easter, who spent a month with Vincent in the Alaskan bush, found inspiration in the experience that he described in his book “The Comfort Crisis,” which details how much of our humanity and health—physical and mental—can be lost when we don’t challenge ourselves or learn to endure hardship.
Vincent documents an elk hunt in Schell Creek Range, Nev., for Men’s Health magazine. (SICMANTA)
Vincent documents an elk hunt in Schell Creek Range, Nev., for Men’s Health magazine. SICMANTA

What’s the ultimate benefit of enduring hardship, according to Vincent? To learn how to contribute back to society, to give to others, to sacrifice self—whether as a husband and father, a soldier, or a hunter. Too much comfort can make us turn inward, make us selfish and unwilling to give for the good of others—and ironically, in so doing, we deny ourselves the greatest gift we can experience.

It’s the greatest gift through showing that I can give to my family, to my community, to my tribe, to show them that when others are in trouble, we rise up and give ourselves to fight. That’s what we do as warriors. That’s what we do as men, that’s what we do as a community,” Vincent says.

Not long ago, he hiked out of the mountains carrying a 130-pound backpack. Walking up a mountain with that kind of weight is a daunting prospect for even the most seasoned mountain man. But Vincent did it to bring back meat for his family, a reality he finds deeply fulfilling. His sense of community extends beyond his family; he has a vision of a society where neighbors selflessly give of themselves and their provisions to one another.

Vincent cooks for the “Comfort Crisis” book crew in the Arctic Circle. On the menu: potatoes, onions, and fresh caribou meat from the day. (SICMANTA)
Vincent cooks for the “Comfort Crisis” book crew in the Arctic Circle. On the menu: potatoes, onions, and fresh caribou meat from the day. SICMANTA

“Nothing by ourselves is meaningful. Nothing. We have to contribute. Being a warrior, being a soldier is fighting for your community,” he says. “When I go hunting, it’s far less serious than that, but I see the same values of [providing] and I get the same feelings.”

“I dream of this world, to be able to kill a deer, butcher it beautifully, come down to your house, and knock on your door and say, ‘Hey, here’s a bunch of steaks for you guys. I picked a bunch of chanterelle mushrooms. I want to share these with you.’”

At the end of the day, Vincent finds providing food for friends, family, and neighbors deeply fulfilling. (SICMANTA)
At the end of the day, Vincent finds providing food for friends, family, and neighbors deeply fulfilling. SICMANTA
This article was originally published in American Essence magazine.
AD