How Secretary of State Races Became Key Focus in Election Integrity Battle

In the wake of the 2020 election, focus sharpened on the 41 state secretaries of state that manage elections; a once obscure position has become a battleground.

Illustration by The Epoch Times, Getty Images, Oregon Secretary of State, Christi Jacobsen for Montana, macwarner.com, Joe Ross, US Department of Education, Freepik

State secretary of state elections were of little interest before 2022, except for those most engaged in statehouse politics. Even the name has a cement reverb.

However, former President Donald Trump’s adamant position about the legitimacy of the 2020 election thrust these usually obscure contests into the spotlight. Several of the 27 secretary of state races in 2022 illustrated sharp divides in elections administration between Republicans and Democrats and exposed fault lines within the GOP.

Midterm state secretary of state races suddenly became acutely partisan with the Democratic Association of Secretaries of State and Republican Secretaries of State Committee collectively funneling more than $75 million into the campaigns, three times more than in 2018.

GOP candidates who backed President Trump’s election fraud allegations formed the America First Secretary of State Coalition. Financially bolstered by Conservatives for Election Integrity PAC, it endorsed 17 candidates. Ten were defeated in primaries and just one, Diego Morales in Indiana, won the general election.

In November, voters in seven states will decide who will fill these consequential secretaries of state seats.

Of the seven races on the November ballot, four are currently held by Democrats: North Carolina, Oregon, Washington, and Vermont. Three are held by Republicans: West Virginia, Montana, and Missouri.

Premium Picks

‘Never Trump’ Billionaires Lead Nikki Haley’s 2023 Fundraising

A ‘Well-Funded Cabal’ Influenced the 2020 Election—What Lies Ahead in 2024?

Nationwide, there are now 26 Republican secretaries of state and 21 Democrats. Alaska, Hawaii, and Utah don’t have the position.

Not all state secretaries of state are equal. In Arizona, Oregon, and Wyoming, the secretary of state is next in the line of succession to the governorship.

Voters elect state secretaries of state in 35 states. Lawmakers in Tennessee, New Hampshire, and Maine appoint them, while the governor does so in nine states. They serve for four years in 41 states, and two years in six.

Secretaries of state generally oversee business and corporate licensing and promote the state in recruiting jobs and investment. They also maintain state records, certify official documents, and regulate charities, securities, and notaries public.

In 41 states, the state secretary of state is also the state’s chief elections officer who orchestrates county elections officials in voter registration, maintenance of voter rolls, and administering elections.

In the wake of the 2020 elections, possessing the levers those 41 state secretaries of state have at their statutory fingertips to influence elections administration was among the grails that guided both parties’ platforms.

Colorado Secretary of State Jena Griswold exits the U.S. Supreme Court in Washington on Feb. 8, 2024. Julia Nikhinson/Getty Images

A similar pattern is unfolding in 2024. Republican secretary of state primaries in North Carolina, West Virginia, and Missouri will be closely contested, while Democrats, other than in Oregon, appear to have a settled roster.

There’s still time for candidates to emerge in five states. Three have filing deadlines in March for May and June primaries. In two, hopefuls have until May to declare for August primaries.

West Virginia: Warner Out, Warner In?

With incumbent Republican Secretary of State Mac Warner running for governor, four GOP rivals are vying in the May 14 primary to take on Democrat attorney Thornton Cooper. The filing deadline was Jan. 27.

West Virginia Economic Development Authority Executive Director Kris Warner, former West Virginia Republican Party chair and Mac Warner’s brother, would sustain his predecessor’s focus on cleaning up voter rolls and prosecuting election fraud.

West Virginia Economic Development Authority Executive Director Kris Warner, who served as state director for rural development in West Virginia in the Trump administration, is one of four candidates seeking to succeed his brother, Mac Warner, as state secretary of state. Kris Warner For WV

“We face challenges from within our party, with individuals who do not share our beliefs. It’s crucial to stop these RINOs [Republicans in Name Only] from diluting our values and infiltrating our party,” Mr. Kris Warner said in announcing his candidacy.

Mr. Warner was the primary front-runner in a Nov. 13–14, 2023, American Pulse Research poll of more than 400 likely voters. The poll found he had 20 percent of the tally, more than double any other candidate. However, 58 percent of respondents were undecided.

Former Berkeley County commissioner and state Del. Ken Reed, a pharmacist, says with experience gained in local government, his emphasis would be on replacing the “older machines” that county elections offices use.

Former West Virginia House Democratic Minority Leader Douglas Skaff Jr. resigned from the Legislature and switched parties in September 2023.

A month later, in his campaign launch, Mr. Skaff vowed to “empower” county elections officials “and provide all election officials and poll workers with the resources to maintain efficient and safe elections.”

Putnam County Clerk and former West Virginia County Clerks Association President Brian Wood says his 18 years of experience in administering 26 federal and state elections gives him “hands-on” insight to “advise and counsel other clerks.”

Oregon: Open Seat on Tap

The Oregon primary is May 21 and the filing deadline is March 14 for an open seat after Democrat Shemia Fagan, elected in 2020, was forced to resign in 2023 when revelations surfaced she was moonlighting as a consultant for a cannabis company that was under her office’s regulatory purview.

A woman (R) posts her ballot at an official drop-off box in Portland, Oregon, on Nov. 8, 2022. The state's mail-in ballots allow Oregonians to fill out their ballots at home with the option to drop them off or mail them in. Mathieu Lewis-Rolland/Getty Images

Oregon Gov. Tina Kotek, a Democrat, appointed LaVonne Griffin-Valade to finish Ms. Fagan’s term. Ms. Griffin-Valade is not seeking election, but her time in office has been substantive in opposing efforts to remove President Trump from the primary ballot and enforcing a 2022 constitutional amendment that disqualifies state lawmakers with 10 or more unexcused absences from legislative sessions from serving another term.

Ten Republican senators tested that amendment by launching the longest quorum-denying walkout in state history in 2023. The six who face 2024 reelections won’t be permitted to run. While two are retiring, the other four are challenging the law in federal lawsuits unlikely to be resolved before the filing deadline, which Ms. Griffin-Valade has vowed to enforce.

Oregon is one of the few states where the Democrat state secretary of state primary could be more contested than the Republican preliminary.

Senate President Pro Tem James Manning, Jr., a 24-year Army veteran, maintains that his two-term Senate track record ensures that voters “can trust James Manning” to be impartial in administering elections.

After Ms. Fagan’s ouster, “trust” is a key attribute in secretary of state elections, he said.

“Trust is something created and earned over time,” Mr. Manning said in announcing his candidacy in September 2023.

Oregon State Treasurer Tobias Read, who served 10 years in the state House before being elected twice to his current post, is seeking to stay in the cabinet.

Defeated by Ms. Kotek in the 2022 gubernatorial primary, Mr. Read maintains that he “will rebuild trust and give voters confidence that their public officials work for the people—and no one else,” he said in launching his campaign in July 2023.

The winner squares off in November against physiologist Brent Barker, who is unchallenged in the Republican primary. An athletic trainer who has worked with NHL, NFL, and Minor League Baseball teams, he’s a first-time political candidate.

Oregon Secretary of State Shemia Fagan was removed in 2023 for moonlighting as a cannabis consultant for a company run by Democratic donors while her office was auditing the industry. Courtesy of Oregon Secretary of State's office

North Carolina: Dem Seeks 7th Term

North Carolina is among the nine states in which the secretary of state is a regulatory officer with little involvement in elections.

Incumbent Democrat North Carolina Secretary of State Elaine Marshall, a fixture for decades, is aiming for a seventh four-year term. sosnc.gov

Incumbent Democrat Elaine Marshall, a fixture for decades, is aiming for a seventh four-year term. She faces no primary opposition.

Of four Democrat-held state secretary of state seats, Ms. Marshall is the only incumbent seeking reelection in a state President Trump won in 2020.

GOP voters will see three party rivals on their March 5 primary ballot.

Gaston County Commissioner Chad Brown, defeated in 2020’s GOP secretary of state primary, is a former minor league baseball pitcher and mayor of Stanley. He has vowed to relieve businesses and taxpayers of “cumbersome” regulations.

Retired Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Carolina executive Jesse “Citizen” Thomas was running for governor but changed course in October 2023. Among his pledges is a promise to sponsor a constitutional amendment to impose term limits on the secretary of state position.

Judicial consultant and former police officer Christine Villaverde, defeated by Rep. Deborah Ross (D-N.C.) in 2022’s congressional races, maintains that her background is suited to “create effective solutions and policies for the problems facing North Carolina and America today.”

A voting booth at a polling location in Clemmons, N.C., on Nov. 8, 2022. Sean Rayford/Getty Images

Montana: Publisher Challenges Incumbent

Montana’s primary is June 4 and the filing deadline is March 11. So far, it’s a two-horse race with the Republican incumbent and Democrat challenger facing no primary opposition.

Montana Secretary of State Christi Jacobsen announced in November 2023 she is seeking a second term. Ballotpedia

Montana Secretary of State Christi Jacobsen announced in November 2023 that she is seeking a second term. A former chief of staff for her predecessor, Corey Stapleton, Ms. Jacobsen’s campaign website touts her performance in strengthening the “integrity and security of state elections.”

She supports the state’s voter ID requirement and assisted the legislature’s drive to end same-day voter registration and restrict third-party ballot collection.

Democrat Jesse James Mullen, a journalist and publisher whose Mullen Newspaper Co. owns 21 newspapers across the West, is the only Democrat registered to challenge Ms. Jacobsen.

In his campaign launch video, Mr. Mullen took direct aim at Ms. Jacobsen, claiming that she pays “nothing more than lip service and empty promises to the issue of fair and open elections” and accused her of “total incompetence” in rolling out new election software in 2022.

Missouri: GOP ‘Civil War’

The primary may be on Aug. 6 and the filing deadline on March 26, but the race for the Republican state secretary of state nod is already playing out on the floor of the Missouri Senate.

Two-term incumbent Republican Secretary of State Jay Ashcroft is running for governor in 2024. As of Feb. 8, four Republicans are running to succeed him while no Democrats have entered the race.

People vote during the primary election at an elementary school in St Louis, Mo., on Aug. 2, 2022. Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images

Two of the candidates—state Senate President Pro Tem Caleb Rowden and Sen. Denny Hoskins—are going at it on a daily basis during the legislative session in Jefferson City, Missouri, in an ongoing “civil war” among Show-Me State Republicans.

Mr. Hoskins is one of six senators in the Missouri Freedom Caucus that Mr. Rowden says foiled attempts since 2021 to pass a law allowing Missouri to join 37 other states with legal sports betting.

That bad blood spilled into the 2024 session in January with Freedom Caucus senators filibustering for 11 hours in a failed attempt to force a vote on a bill making it harder for citizen-initiated petitions to get constitutional amendments on the ballot.

Missouri state Sen. Denny Hoskins is one of four Republicans running in the primary for state secretary of state. senate.mo.gov

In response, Mr. Rowden banned the six from parking in the capitol complex basement, slashed their office budgets, and stripped three of them of their committee chairmanships. Mr. Hoskins was removed as Economic Development and Tax Policy Committee chair and lost his Senate Appropriations Committee seat.

In a press conference, Mr. Rowden called the Freedom Caucus “a small group of swamp creatures” who made “the beginning of the 2024 legislative session ... nothing short of an embarrassment.”

Mr. Hoskins countered that Mr. Rowden isn’t acting as a legislative leader but as a candidate attempting to undercut a rival.

“Sen. Rowden is using the same playbook that Joe Biden is using on President Trump to silence me and win and beat me in a statewide race by using his position of power to be punitive,” Mr. Hoskins told reporters.

Mr. Rowden, in public comments and on his campaign website, has been short on specifics about what he would do as secretary of state, stating that the office is defined “by competency and not by chaos.”

Mr. Hoskins, in public comments and on his campaign website, stated that he’ll focus on tightening voter ID and ballot drop box rules while strengthening a 2022 state law that mandates paper ballots but allows them to be machine-counted.

Missouri Senate President Pro Tem Caleb Rowden, one of four GOP state secretary of state candidates, addresses a joint session of American Legion Auxiliary Missouri Girls State and American Legion Boys State of Missouri in St. Charles, Mo., in June 2023. Friends of Caleb Rowden

Mr. Hoskins has a 2024 proposal to repeal that law and require paper ballots to be hand-counted. Bipartisan opponents say that would result in elections taking weeks, even months, to certify, but, he maintains, hand-counts won’t be an issue “as long as we have the manpower to do it.”

Another candidate, two-term state Rep. Adam Schwadron called Mr. Hoskins’ hand-count initiative unrealistic in larger counties and said he’ll push for tighter absentee ballot signature verification.

Candidate and business owner Valentina Gomez Noriega, 24, doesn’t address election-related issues on her campaign website but said she will “fight for transparency where you can see every decision, every dollar, and every promise.”

Washington: No Official Candidates

The primary is Aug. 6 with a May 10 filing deadline. As of Feb.8, there are no candidates.

Despite being a blue state, Republicans won every state secretary of state election from 1964 to 2022 in Washington.

Washington Secreatry of State Steve Hobbs, a Democrat, is running for reelection after winning a 2022 special election. Public Domain

Three-term Republican Kim Wyman resigned in November 2021 to join the federal Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA).

Democrat Gov. Jay Inslee appointed state Sen. Steve Hobbs to fill the post. Mr. Hobbs then won a 2022 special election, defeating independent Julie Anderson after no Republicans emerged from the state’s ranked vote primary. It was the first time a Democrat held the post in 60-plus years.

Mr. Hobbs has not indicated if he will run for a full term. He is under fire after approving a $273,000 no-bid contract with a British company to track “in real time election misinformation and disinformation.”

The Washington Republican Party filed a Nov. 30, 2023, complaint with the state Executive Ethics Board that claims Mr. Hobbs is violating the constitution and his oath of office by hiring a tech firm to scour social media “to suppress and abridge free speech on a massive scale.”

Sen. Josh Hawley, (R-Mo.), questions Mark Zuckerberg, CEO of Facebook, about censorship during a Senate hearing at the U.S. Capitol on Nov. 17, 2020. Bill Clark-Pool/Getty Images

Vermont: Two-Year Terms

The primary is Aug. 13 with a May 30 filing deadline. As of Feb. 8, there are no candidates.

Incumbent Democrat Sarah Copeland Hanzas, who served in the Vermont House from 2004–22, hasn’t indicated if she will seek a second term after winning the post in 2022. Vermont secretaries of state serve two-year terms.

Ms. Copeland Hanzas maintained that a secretary of state plays a “non-partisan role ... overseeing free, fair, accessible and transparent elections.” She has rebuffed attempts to exclude Mr. Trump from the 2024 ballot.

In a widely published December 2023 op-ed, Ms. Copeland Hanzas said under state law, the secretary of state “has no role in making a legal determination” on the former president’s ballot eligibility.

“Our role, as directed by statute, is to place any person’s name on the Presidential Primary ballot if that person files the requisite number of signatures, consent form, and filing fee prior to the deadline on Dec. 15, 2023.”